clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Giants news, 9/23: Fallout from 49ers game, PFF grades, Saquon Barkley, more headlines

New York Giants news for Saturday

If you buy something from an SB Nation link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

Good morning, New York Giants fans!

Giants-49ers ‘Kudos & Wet Willies’: Is the Giants’ defense off the field yet?

BBV's Ed Valentine reviews Thursday’s game in his traditional style.

More from Big Blue View

Other Giant observations

Saquon Barkley's immense value magnified in Giants' loss to 49ers | FOX Sports

With Barkley watching from the sidelines the Giants had their lowest offensive output in 10 years in their 30-12 loss to the 49ers — an abysmal 150 yards. That included a measly 29 yards rushing on just 11 carries.

And with the threat of Barkley gone, they had no play-action or RPO game at all to throw the 49ers' pass rush off-balance. They were basically forced to play a completely different offense than they know how to play. Since Brian Daboll arrived as head coach last year, the Giants' best play — by far— has been when quarterback Daniel Jones runs the ball.

Daniel Jones after the loss to the 49ers

New York Giants Are a 1-2 Team That Looks Like an 0-3 Team | The 33rd Team

Rondé Barber says the New York Giants’ offense looked stuck in mud vs. the San Francisco 49ers. He says the Giants are a 1-2 team that looks like an 0-3 team, and if they can’t operate without Saquon Barkley, they are going to be in for a long season.

New York Giants' Team Identity Taking Shape--and It's Not a Good One | Sports Illustrated's Patricia Traina weighs in:

The Giants simply haven't been good enough to stand on the same field as some of the competition they've faced this season. They've been lacking in executing the fundamentals--see the 16 missed tackles or their inability to get off the field on third down, particularly in the first half when the 49ers converted seven of nine attempts--and have yet to define who or what they are as a football team.

What they aren't, at least right now, is a very good football team, not if you compare them to the Dallas Cowboys or the San Francisco 49ers, the two teams that steamrolled the Giants en route to wins by at least two scores.

Tiki calls out Giants effort on defense notes missed tackles |

The Giants missed several tackles in their loss to the 49ers on Thursday night, and Tiki called out the defense’s effort in the 30-12 defeat.

“That’s effort,” Tiki said. “There was one in particular, Elijah Mitchell had an outside zone run in the second quarter, and you just saw the rookie [Tre] Hawkins, he just turned it down. He didn’t even try. He tried to go low, but he barely made contact, and he clips off 18 yards and you get into scoring position. It’s effort. To me, that’s effort. I know cornerbacks don’t want to hit anymore. I know they don’t think they need to tackle on the edges and think they’re just there to contain and drive a guy inside. But when you’re the last line of defense, that’s an effort thing. That’s a want-to thing.”

Honestly, this has happened too many times over the last two years

Giants are 1-2 with a minus-55 point differential, so why are they still so confident about their season? |

For the second time in three games, the Giants walked off the field having been thoroughly thumped by an opponent.

This wasn’t as bad as the forty-point beating they took from the Dallas Cowboys on opening night, but the 30-12 loss to the San Francisco 49ers did provide more evidence that the Giants are not among the NFL’s elite. The Giants remain confident they are a good football team even if their early-season results mostly say otherwise.

NY Giants vs. 49ers: Takeaways from Thursday night loss | The Record

Here’s a team that struggled with missed tackles trying to improve against the 49ers, who feature Christian McCaffrey, George Kittle and Deebo Samuel. That’s not a winning proposition. This is something the Giants need to improve, or it’s going to be a long year for this defense.

“If we did our job, we would have won the game,” cornerback Adoree’ Jackson said. “We played hard, with grit and with will, but if you lose, it doesn’t matter. We didn’t execute, didn’t tackle and didn’t get off the field [on third down].”

Handed another lopsided loss, Giants’ reality is they’re far from team they hoped to be | The Athletic

This matchup didn’t lend itself to deep shots for wide receiver Jalin Hyatt, who dazzled with two catches for 89 yards in Week 2. Hyatt, who remains fourth in the wide receiver pecking order, didn’t have a target on Thursday. He got wide-open once on a deep route in the second quarter, but Jones didn’t see him as he fled the pocket and threw the ball away.

“We called a fair amount of (deep shots),” Daboll said. “A couple of times we had them, and the protection leaked. They covered them. It was a delicate balance with that defensive line that they’ve got. You’ve got to decide how many guys you keep in to help out the protection to make sure you can get off more vertical routes versus getting it out a little quicker.”

Coach Brian Daboll’s audition for the Manningcast

Notes & Stats: Thursday Night Football Recap |

The Giants were surpassed in all major statistical categories, including total yards (441-150), rushing yards (141-29), passing yards (300-121), first downs (26-10), third-down conversions and time of possession (39:10-20:50).

A statistical review of Week 3 Thursday Night Football: New York Giants' offensive struggles continue | PFF

Given the non-functional passing game, it’s hard to find a receiver who stood out for the New York Giants. The Giants couldn’t get much done after the catch, as leading targets Darius Slayton and Darren Waller combined for only six total yards after the catch.

The 49ers receivers did most of their damage after the catch, as their three leading receivers had an average depth of target of 7.1, 7.5 and -2.2, respectively.

NOTE: ‘SB Nation Reacts’ polling for the above graphic was done prior to Thursday’s loss to San Francisco.]

Around the league

Tropical Cyclone could affect Bills at Commanders, Ravens at Colts and Patriots at Jets |

Curtis Samuel questionable, Logan Thomas out for Commanders | Pro Football Talk

Eagles HC Nick Sirianni on balancing workload for RB D'Andre Swift: 'We're going to ride the hot hand' |

Mike McCarthy defends drill that led to Trevon Diggs injury | Pro Football Talk

QB Anthony Richardson (concussion) out, Gardner Minshew to start for Colts vs. Ravens |

Panthers’ Bryce Young to miss 1-2 weeks; Andy Dalton starting |

Joe Burrow throws during individual drills on Friday | Pro Football Talk

Browns RB Kareem Hunt will make season debut vs. Titans |

Chad Henne says he turned down opportunity with Jets after Aaron Rodgers injury |

All eyes on Jawaan Taylor as he attempts to fix his penalty problem |

Andrew Luck brings 'Captain Andrew Luck' meme to life by dressing up in Civil War attire for 'TNF' broadcast |

The 2023 Miami Dolphins Have Evolved. That Should Worry the Entire AFC. | The Ringer

BBV mailbag

Have a Giants-related question? E-mail it to and it might be featured in our weekly mailbag.

BBV podcast

You can find and subscribe to Big Blue View radio from the show’s home page

BBV YouTube

You can find and subscribe to Big Blue View YouTube from the show’s home page

BBV on Twitter: Follow @BigBlueView

Ed Valentine: Follow @Valentine_Ed

BBV on Facebook: Click here to like the Big Blue View Facebook page

BBV on YouTube: Subscribe to the Big Blue View YouTube channel

BBV on Instagram: Click here to follow our Instagram page

BBV podcasts: Click here to subscribe to BBV Radio