Its become fairly evident lo these many weeks that Gillan is not the answer at punter. Since the Seahawks game he's been very consistently inconsistent. He's costed us dearly in terms of field position for 5 weeks in a row. So how about trading in a hammer for a god?
Now, most of you remember Araiza for the disgusting allegations that came to light after the draft. However, it appears those allegations were overblown. Despite all the fanfare after the draft, he is not going to be charged. He still has all the talent that convinced the Bills to draft him. He may be an idiot, but that's a long ways away from being a criminal, and players have been signed after being accused of far worse. I'd say he's worth a pick up.