clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Giants news, 3/21: Phil Simms offers Giants advice with No. 2 pick

What would the former quarterback do with the pick?

Wyoming v UNLV
Josh Allen
Photo by Ethan Miller/Getty Images

What would Phil Simms do with the second overall pick in the 2018 NFL Draft if he was in Dave Gettleman’s shoes? Here is what Simms told Adam Schein Tuesday on Sirius XM NFL Radio about how he believes the New York Giants should approach the pick.

“Listen, are they going to trade the second pick, let’s say, to Buffalo for the 12th pick and whatever and all this other stuff? Quite honestly, I don’t think it’s a great draft this year, Adam. When I look at it, it’s not like last year when you can get a fourth round guy and the guy can start and be an All Pro player. Last year’s draft was phenomenal. I don’t feel that when I look at the players this year,” Simms said.

“I haven’t gone that deep into [it] yet but I will before draft day, that’s for sure. And I think the fan base, I hate to say it, but you think the fans are going to be happy if the Giants move back and get the 12th pick and twenty-something pick and do all that? No. They want a superstar. What do they see? What are they going to build? Are we going to try to win this thing next year with Eli Manning and the moves they’re making and all that? If you’re going to do that then it’s [Saquon] Barkley without question. But if you’re looking anything into the future, if Josh Allen is sitting there and they don’t take him then I would think they would get a ransom for Josh Allen. So if Cleveland takes Sam Darnold, or Barkley, and Josh Allen is sitting there, that would be interesting. I think Cleveland will take a quarterback first so the Giants are going to be sitting there and if Josh Allen is there and Barkley is there, then there are going to be a lot of teams flying up there to get that pick for Josh Allen, I think.”

Simms also knows what he would do if he was Cleveland Browns GM John Dorsey:

“If it was me, just off what I’ve seen and everything, yes, without question Josh Allen would be my number one pick if I was the Cleveland Browns.”

More headlines

WATCH: Saquon Barkley explains decision to not work out during Penn State's Pro Day

Crabbs | QB Baker Mayfield scouting report | NDT Scouting
With the culmination of my Draft work in 2018 nearly here (my 2018 Prospectus of 300 NFL Draft prospects will be released next Monday), I now have the opportunity to share with you all some sample reports from this year's edition. First up? My top eligible Quarterback and the 2017 Heisman Trophy winner, Oklahoma's

2018 NFL Draft: Best Fits for Top QBs After Early Free-Agency Action | Bleacher Report
There are two kinds of teams in today's NFL . There are those that have stability at the quarterback position, and there are those that don't. The haves spend their offseasons trying to surround their signal-callers with talent...

Underrated RB Prospects with Chance to Be the Next Kareem Hunt or Alvin Kamara | Bleacher Report
Top-notch running backs are frequently mined from the NFL draft's middle or late rounds. In 2017, for example, third-round Toledo product Kareem Hunt led the league in rushing ...

Justin Tuck: Giants should take Saquon Barkley with No. 2 pick in NFL Draft | Newsday
The Giants’ former All-Pro defensive end doesn’t think they should take a quarterback because he says 37-year-old Eli Manning has multiple years left in him.

Josh Allen thinks better footwork will lead to better accuracy – ProFootballTalk
Quarterback Josh Allen will throw for scouts at Wyoming's Pro Day on Friday, although there probably aren't too many questions about his arm strength at the pre-draft process. Allen has shown more than once that can throw the ball hard and he can throw it a long way.

[E-mail Ed at or via the Big Blue View Contact Page | Follow Big Blue View on Twitter | ‘Like’ Big Blue View on Facebook]