clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Giants news, 2/15: Josh Rosen compares to Eli Manning, more

An interesting take on the UCLA QB leads today’s headlines

If you buy something from an SB Nation link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

Josh Rosen
Photo by Josh Lefkowitz/Getty Images

Josh Rosen is Eli Manning. That conclusion, from Pro Football Focus draft analyst Steve Palazzolo, should get the attention of New York Giants fans. Rosen, of course, is the player most often mocked to the Giants as the heir apparent to Manning at quarterback for the Giants.

Palazzolo wrote that while Rosen’s final numbers show year-to-year consistency “when it comes to a game-by-game or throw-by-throw basis, he’s actually closer to a high-volatile player in the mold of Eli Manning or Jameis Winston.”

Here is Palazzolo’s full conclusion about Rosen:

Understanding the good and bad that Rosen brings to the table is crucial to his evaluation. From his ability to make plays at the intermediate level to his feel for all necessary NFL throws, Rosen has the skills and aggressiveness to create downfield opportunities at the next level. However, the same aggressiveness that leads to the special plays also leads to far too many turnover-worthy plays. We’ve seen other quarterbacks have success with this style, and there’s certainly an argument to be made that a quarterback capable of adding value, rather than just avoiding turnovers, is preferable.

It’s important to understand that those strengths and weaknesses will work hand in hand, and the top end of Rosen’s play will lead to special games, and perhaps even special seasons, much like Eli Manning has shown throughout his career.

More headlines

2018 NFL Draft Big Board: Top 50 Prospects |
Saquon Barkley is at the top of a draft class heavy on first-round quarterbacks

NY Giants: 5 things to watch and what's next moving forward
Pat Shurmur's staff is complete, the Combine is in 2 weeks and free agency is on the horizon. Here are 5 things to watch as NY Giants move forward.

Dez Bryant, Jordy Nelson among NFC cut candidates -
Is Dez Bryant's time with the Dallas Cowboys drawing to an end? Will the Green Bay Packers bid adieu to Jordy Nelson? Gregg Rosenthal lists notable cut candidates in the NFC.

Tyrod Taylor, DeMarco Murray among AFC cut candidates -
Is the Tyrod Taylor era finally coming to a close in Buffalo? Gregg Rosenthal runs through notable players in the AFC who are candidates to be released this offseason.

Mike Shula's impact on Eli Manning, other Giants QBs | Closer look at his quarterback resume |
Mike Shula coached former NFL MVP Cam Newton for 7 seasons with Panthers. Who else has he mentored? What are the results?

New York Giants, collectors trade barbs in memorabilia fraud lawsuit
Lawyers for the collectors continued to assert their claims that the Giants, Eli Manning and others were complicit in memorabilia fraud. The Giants' attorneys, meanwhile, maintained that the collectors have yet to prove the team has done anything wrong.

Charley Casserly explains why UCLA Quarterback Josh Rosen can be the QB of the future for the New York Giants - NFL Videos
NFL Network's Charley Casserly breaks down the top two picks in his first 2018 mock draft.

Meet Pat Shurmur’s staff, which is a lot different than McAdoo’s | New York Post
Pat Shurmur is in the final stages of completing his coaching staff, and it bears only a slight resemblance to the one left behind by Ben McAdoo. Most notably,...

[E-mail Ed at or via the Big Blue View Contact Page | Follow Big Blue View on Twitter | ‘Like’ Big Blue View on Facebook]