Here is my list. Drop yours in the comments.
No. 4: Super Bowl XXI — Giants 39, Broncos 20
The Giants’ first Super Bowl title. So many great memories. Phil Simms’ MVP performance. Phil McConkey’s near touchdown, followed by a real touchdown. A goal-line stand from the 1-yard line. George Martin’s sack of John Elway for a safety starting a 26-0 run for the Giants. Still, this ended up as a blowout.
No. 3: Super Bowl XLVI — Giants 21, Patriots 17
A second Super Bowl upset of the New England Patriots during the Tom Coughlin/Eli Manning era. That throw from Manning to Mario Manningham may be the most precise pass Manning has ever delivered. The Giants once again used their “beat up Tom Brady” formula. Will Matt Ryan and the Atlanta Falcons wreck the Giants’ standing as the only team to have beaten Brady/Bill Belichick in a Super Bowl?
No. 2: Super Bowl XXV — Giants 20, Bills 19
Three plays stand out. Wide right by Buffalo kicker Scott Norwood, obviously. The Ottis Anderson uppercut. Mark Ingram fighting through Bills’ defenders for a first down on third-and-13, a play that led to the Giants scoring a touchdown.
No. 1: Super Bowl XLII — Giants 17, Patriots 14
David Tyree helmet catch. Patriots 18-1. Enough said.