clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

2015 NFL mock draft roundup: Comparing seven-round Giants mock drafts

New, comments

Let's look at two seven-round mocks for the Giants.

Jerry Lai-USA TODAY Sports

It is time for our weekly mock draft roundup, where we look around the Inter-Google at recent mock draft selections for the New York Giants. Let's do something a little different this week. Let's begin by comparing a pair of recent seven-round mock drafts.

In the first table below are choices made for the Giants in a pair of seven-round mock drafts, one from Draft Tek and the other from Matt Miller of Bleacher Report. Which do you find more likely? Which do you prefer?

Personally, I find the Draft Tek mock to be intriguing and I can see an argument for the first couple of selections. I find the first two selections of the Miller mock draft to be more likely, however. The path of the Miller mock is also more palatable to me, though I wonder about the selection of two late-round tight ends.

One thing neither mock addresses in any real sense is the pass rush.

Your thoughts on these, Giants fans?

Draft Tek B/R (Miller)
Rd. 1 (9) Trae Waynes, CB, Mich. St. Brandon Scherff, OL, Iowa
Rd. 2 (40) Maxx Williams, TE, Minnesota Denzel Perryman, MLB, Miami
Rd. 3 (74) Gerod Holliman, FS, Louisville Sammie Coates, WR, Auburn
Rd. 4 (108) Jamil Douglas, G, Arizona St. Adrian Amos, S, Penn St.
Rd. 5 (144) Justin Hardy, WR, East Carolina Imoan Claiborne, CB, N'western St.
Rd. 6 (185) Bryce Hager, MLB, Baylor Jesse James, TE, Penn St.
Rd. 7 (226) Jalston Fowler, FB, Alabama Sean Hickey, OT, Syracuse
Rd. 7 (245) Chucky Hunter, DT, TCU E.J. Bibbs, TE, Iowa St.

Now, here is our weekly table of first-round mock draft choices. There are 12 of them listed this week, with four agreeing with my choice of Brandon Scherff in the SBN bloggers' mock draft. After that, a mixed bag with wide receiver Amari Cooper and defensive tackle Malcom Brown each selected twice.

Your thoughts on these, Giants fans?

Mock Draft Player Position College Updated
Mocking The Draft Brandon Scherff OL Iowa 3/23
Draft Tek Trae Waynes CB Mich. State 3/23
Bleacher Report/Miller Brandon Scherff OT Iowa 3/24
Walter Football Amari Cooper WR Alabama 3/25
CBS Sports/Rang Randy Gregory DE Nebraska 3/23
CBS Sports/Brugler Shane Ray DE Missouri 3/23
NY Daily News/Samuel Brandon Scherff OL Iowa 3/26
CBS Sports/Prisco Brandon Scherff OL Iowa 3/24
Ourlads Malcom Brown DT Texas 3/20
Great Blue North Draft Report Amari Cooper WR Alabama 3/23
NFL.com/Davis Malcom Brown DT Texas 3/25
NFL.com/Brooks Landon Collins SS Alabama 3/23