clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Let's name an all-time team

Here's a little off-season activity that should be fun. Let's name the Big Blue View All-Time Giants' Team.

With the help of George Cronin and 'potroast,' two veteran members of Big Blue View Nation, I have compiled lists of what we believe to be the best players at each position throughout Giants' history.

Occasionally throughout the off-season I will give you a position, and the candidates we have chosen, and ask you to vote for the player you feel belongs on our All-Time Team.

I will place a poll at the bottom of each entry in the series. You will have at least four players, sometimes more, to choose from. I will leave each poll open for a few days. Obviously, the player who gets the highest percentage of the vote at each position will be named to the team. In the case of positions like defensive end, the top two vote-getters will make the squad.

I don't want to start with a glamour position, so I will start with the kickers. Let's go with the punters first.

All-Time Punting Nominees

• Jeff Feagles
• Sean Landeta
• Don Chandler
• Dave Jennings

I don't have a schedule yet for when these will appear. I will let you know as we go along.

One request. Please don't skew the results by voting over and over. Nobody wins anything here, so that doesn't help anything. I just want to have a little fun and see what we come up with.

NOTE: If you don't see the poll here at the bottom, click "Entry Link" and you will be taken to a page that includes the poll.


Who is the best punter in New York Giants' history?

This poll is closed

  • 37%
    Jeff Feagles
    (25 votes)
  • 40%
    Sean Landeta
    (27 votes)
  • 6%
    Don Chandler
    (4 votes)
  • 15%
    Dave Jennings
    (10 votes)
66 votes total Vote Now