clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Third pick a surprise

The giants used their third-round pick on Jay Alford, a 6-foot-3, 304-pound defensive tackle from Penn State.

I am very surprised by that choice. There were several linebackers still on the board who figured to be mid-third round type selections -- including Zak DeOssie (Brown), Stewart Bradley (Nebraska) and Tim Shaw (Penn State). I would have gone after one of those guys with this pick.

Another option here would have been tight end Ben Patrick of Delaware.

That is not to say, however, that choosing a defensive tackle was a horrible idea. If it means less playing time for the useless William Joseph, or the possibility he could be released altogether, fabulous.

Alford, however, seems to be a bit of a reach. Most boards had him going in the middle of the second day, so GM Jerry Reese and the Giants must see him differently than other teams.

Here is the skinny from Yahoo! Sports.

The good: Alford has the explosive first step and quick hands that give him a fast advantage over blockers early in the down. ... Alford shows fine instincts to locate the ball quickly and the closing burst of speed to make the big play. ... He is an explosive, disruptive, one-gap type of tackle with a fine first step.

The bad: His lack of prototypical size will probably put him behind the top prospects, but his playmaking ability and production can rival most prospects in this class. His lack of bulk makes it difficult for him to stack on the inside and hold the point of attack against NFL-caliber linemen.

Outlook: He is a quick, undersized defender with the athletic ability, big-game experience and production to become an NFL tackle - but only in the right scheme.

Your thoughts?