Overrated/Underrated?

Overrated=Baas but it is his first year
Underrated=“bubble butt” Boothe
Rookie J williams
Draft= OT and you can never have enough DE and CB in the league today

As said above its NY. I think Eli is to focused on machanics and gameplan in the beginning, but once he figures out what the defense is doing and goes with the flow that when we see the yards and point start to rack up. He’s the guy that calls and checks all night at the joker table, then once he knows your sytle he’s all in.

Overrated – Mark Herzlich
Underrated- Kenny Phillips
Rookie – jacquan williams
Draft – OT, OG/C, TE, LB, RB, S in that order

Who is the most overrated player on the team? – Snee/McKenzie in the media, not the force they once were

Who is the most underrated player on the team? – Will Beatty

Who is your choice for best rookie on the Giants? – J Williams, he’s going to open some eyes next year

What do the Giants need to address in the 2012 draft? – Nothing is a screaming need, LB, CB, OL all could use some more youth and talent. Maybe a pass rushing DE if we deal Osi

Does coach Tom Coughlin deserve all the scrutiny he gets from the media? – NO, he’s a solid Coach

Why does it seem the Giants don’t get things moving until the second quarter? In other words, why do the Giants fail to play up to their skill level in the first quarter of most games? The design of the Giant offense isn’t West Coast. It’s somewhat harder to operate and part is seeing how teams are reacting to you. But it allows for more big plays.

Who is the most overrated player on the team? Jonathan Goff, even though he is on IR now that the defense is coming together and Chase Blackburn has filled in his spot, not really missing him. Not the monster PFF makes him out to be

Who is the most underrated player on the team? Eli Manning, not by BBV but by the national media, when he made his comment that he was an elite QB the likes of Brady and PManning everyone went nuts. I think that nonsense can be put to rest

Who is your choice for best rookie on the Giants? Jacquain Williams, this is more outta default, most of the other rookies didnt make much of an impact

What do the Giants need to address in the 2012 draft? Easy answer MLB position. We having been plugging adequate answers for the past couple of years. It would be nice to have an impact player at the position.

Does coach Tom Coughlin deserve all the scrutiny he gets from the media? No

Why does it seem the Giants don’t get things moving until the second quarter? In other words, why do the Giants fail to play up to their skill level in the first quarter of most games? It seems like both coordinators are reacting to what the opponent is doing and then making adjustments after halftime which works fine a majority of the time. We’ve settled for the fact that we arent going to be the ‘greatest show on turf’

Who is the most overrated player on the team? – Chris Snee

Who is the most underrated player on the team? – Kiwi

Who is your choice for best rookie on the Giants? – Jac Will

What do the Giants need to address in the 2012 draft? – Secondary and Linebackers

Does coach Tom Coughlin deserve all the scrutiny he gets from the media? – no

Overrated – I think McKenzie best fits at this point. He’s still treated as an elite RT when he’s really lost a step or two. Others: Osi, Snee, possibly Ballard.
Underrated – Nicks when healthy; Nicks is a top-5 receiver when healthy and I don’t think he gets viewed that way in the media. Others; DJ Ware (blitz pickup especially), Canty.
Best rookie – Williams (but I still believe in Prince long-term)
Draft needs – OL, TE, LB
Coughlin appraisal: I think sometimes, things need to change. Bill Walsh said something like “things should change after 10 years max so that things don’t get stale.” I suspect Coughlin’s shtick would get there at some point but I think he’ll retire before it happens.