After the jump you will find a really incredible chart put together by a Big Blue View reader, Don Mushinsky. Don is taking the stance that New York Giants general manager Jerry Reese, thought of as a premier talent evaluator, has actually not done all that well in the NFL Draft.
In fact, Don calls Reese "a very poor GM" and labels his draft record "abysmal."
To be honest, I disagree. I have said many times that since 2007 the only poor draft I think Reese has had was the 2009 class, out of which right now only Hakeem Nicks and Will Beatty are regular, productive players. That could change, but the signs are not good.
Still, I thought this work was well done and worthy of being brought to your attention. Check it out after the jump.
Bust defined as draft choice that was with team 1 year or less and/or made no contribution to his position on NYG in regular season
| Round | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL | % of Draft Pick that went bust | Draft Grade |
| 1 | 19 | Prince Amukamara | DB | Nebraska | TBD | |
| 2 | 52 | Marvin Austin | DT | North Carolina | ||
| 3 | 83 | Jerrel Jernigan | WR | Troy | ||
| 4 | 117 | James Brewer | T | Indiana | ||
| 6 | 185 | Greg Jones | LB | Michigan State | ||
| 6 | 198 | Tyler Sash | DB | Iowa | ||
| 6 | 202 | Jacquian Williams | LB | South Florida | ||
| 7 | 221 | Da'Rel Scott | RB | Maryland | ||
| 2010 | ||||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL | 50% | C |
| 1 | 15 | Jason Pierre-Paul | DE | South Florida | ||
| 2 | 46 | Linval Joseph | DT | East Carolina | ||
| 4 | 115 | Phillip Dillard | LB | Nebraska | Bust | |
| 5 | 147 | Mitch Petrus | G | Arkansas | ||
| 6 | 184 | Adrian Tracy | LB | William & Mary | Bust | |
| 7 | 221 | Matt Dodge | P | East Carolina | Bust | |
| 2009 | ||||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL | 78% | D- |
| 1 | 29 | Hakeem Nicks | WR | North Carolina | ||
| 2 | 45 | Clint Sintim | LB | Virginia | Bust | |
| 2 | 60 | William Beatty | T | Connecticut | ||
| 3 | 85 | Ramses Barden | WR | Cal Poly-S.L.O. | Bust | |
| 3 | 100 | Travis Beckum | TE | Wisconsin | Bust | |
| 4 | 129 | Andre Brown | RB | North Carolina State | Bust | |
| 5 | 151 | Rhett Bomar | QB | Sam Houston State | Bust | |
| 6 | 200 | DeAndre Wright | CB | New Mexico | Bust | |
| 7 | 238 | Stoney Woodson | CB | South Carolina | Bust | |
| 2008 | ||||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL | 43% | B- |
| 1 | 31 | Kenny Phillips | FS | Miami (Fla.) | ||
| 2 | 63 | Terrell Thomas | CB | USC | ||
| 3 | 95 | Mario Manningham | WR | Michigan | ||
| 4 | 123 | Bryan Kehl | OLB | Brigham Young | Bust | |
| 5 | 165 | Jonathan Goff | LB | Vanderbilt | ||
| 6 | 198 | Andre Woodson | QB | Kentucky | Bust | |
| 6 | 199 | Robert Henderson | DE | Southern Mississippi | Bust | |
| 2007 | ||||||
| RD | SEL # | PLAYER | POSITION | SCHOOL | 38% | B |
| 1 | 20 | Aaron Ross | CB | Texas | ||
| 2 | 51 | Steve Smith | WR | USC | ||
| 3 | 81 | Jay Alford | NT | Penn State | Bust | |
| 4 | 116 | Zak DeOssie | LB | Brown | ||
| 5 | 153 | Kevin Boss | TE | Western Oregon | ||
| 6 | 189 | Adam Koets | T | Oregon State | Bust | |
| 7 | 224 | Michael Johnson | SAF | Arizona | Bust | |
| 7 | 250 | Ahmad Bradshaw | RB | Marshall |
There are 275 Comments. Load Now.
Shortcuts to mastering the comment thread. Use wisely.
C - Next Comment
X - Mark as Read
R - Reply
Z - Mark Read & Next
Shift + C - Previous
Shift + A - Mark All Read
Comment Settings
Live comment alert: Hide it!
Comments for this post are closed.