Free-Agent Frenzy: Giants' Front Office Should Be Up To This Task
Pro Football Talk was recently discussing how the frenzied free-agent period that will occur will separate the best of the NFL's front offices from the rest.
"What’s going to happen is you’re going to have some inexperienced general managers and owners go crazy early on," one longtime G.M. told SI.com’s Don Banks. "They’re going to think, ‘I’ve got to go out and do something crazy. This is my window of opportunity.’ But I think that’s absolutely the wrong move.
"There are so many free agents and so many guys out there that if you’re just patient, you can wind up with some good players at really good value and not put yourself out there [at risk] with a couple mega-deals."
This is one reason why I feel good that the Giants are in the hands of general manager Jerry Reese, coach Tom Coughlin and owner John Mara. Aside from some Coughlin histrionics and bright-red cheeks when things are not going well, when do the Giants ever "go crazy?"
The answer is, they don't. They always keep their feet on the ground.
The Giants never approach free agency in panic mode, a la the Washington Redskins, blindly throwing big dollars at big names in the vain hope that -- while they have gotten it wrong almost every other time they have tried it -- this time they will get it right.
That's not to say the Giants have not overpaid for players at times -- you can still argue that Rocky Bernard, Chris Canty and Antrel Rolle were given too much money, if you like. It is to say that the Giants always have a plan. They know what they need, they know which of their own free agents they would like to retain and at what cost, and they have a pretty good idea what players they would like to pursue on the open market.
We keep reading about how active and aggressive the Philadelphia Eagles will be in free agency. Not a peep has really been uttered about the Giants. I am, however, supremely confident that the Giants know what they want to accomplish and that, when the curtain finally rises on the 2011 season, no one in the Giants offices will be sweating bullets and thinking 'Oh my God, how do I handle this?'
Does that mean we know exactly how the Ahmad Bradshaw, Steve Smith, Osi Umenyiora, Mathias Kiwanuka and Barry Cofield situations will turn out? No. It also doesn't mean we know which free agents from other teams the Giants will target, or ultimately sign.
It means that, whatever the rules are and whatever the time frame teams are working with, Giants fans should feel comfortable that their team's decision-makers will be up to the task.
29 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Agreed
I think all Giant fans should feel good about our front office, especially in the current situation they will be facing, i have all the faith in world they’ll make the right moves
Thank You Donnie, Mr. Dolan please don't do the unthinkable
by colinlovestheknicks on Jul 11, 2011 10:59 AM EDT reply actions
In defense of the Canty, Bernard and Rolle contracts
Those contracts weren’t out of line for the free agent market. We can say Canty is overpaid, but good players get overpaid in free agency. At the conclusion of 2008 we had 2 starting DTs facing knee surgery. What was the alternative? Viable starting DTs had to be brought in, and since then the team has spent 2 #2’s on the position.
It says to me, that at the end of 2008, the coaches and GM were as stressed about DT as the fans were about WR.
I agree
I didn’t say that I think those guys are overpaid. I was trying to say that I know there is an argument many will make that they are overpaid.
by Ed Valentine on Jul 11, 2011 11:50 AM EDT up reply actions
I got it
Call it me being more tired of the complaints than you.
I also agree, as the same can be said about Rolle
Rolle got a HUGE contract, and I know some may think “was it worth it”, but you have to take in consideration the situation the G’s where in at the end of that year. God awfull safety play without K.P. who was/ or was not coming back from his injuries, and Rolle was the most talented Safety on the market, which would give use an instant boost at that postition. Rolle has diffenitly done this plu, I think he has a lot more to prove playing for the giants.
Yup.
It’s so easy to critisize, but people often forget the situation the team was in when they make a signing. I am supremely confident in our General Manager and coach to get the right players. They don’t have a perfect track record, but who does?
Just get it done already...
Agreed
I’m confident that Reese will approach FA in the same manner he did the draft… And I think that turned out fairly well. Let everyone else go nuts and make headlines, Reese will go cherry picking.
Boss, SS12, Kiwi, and AB will all get resigned. They’ll make an offer to Cofield, but Minnesota or Denver will make a bigger one, and they’ll lose him (and possibly get a 3rd round comp pick if they exist in the next CBA… so w00t for that).
Then I think they’ll grab either Rocky McIntosh, or Manny Lawson for SAM, and maybe the C from Arizona (get Rolle to do some recruiting).
Don't the Eagles and Redskins
have to spend a tone of money? Everything I’m reading says they will be way under the “salary cap” floor, while the Giants and Boys will be over it.
Your First Ever Pinstripe Bowl Champions- The Syracuse Orange
by bigbluethruandthru on Jul 11, 2011 11:33 AM EDT reply actions
PFT posted what would the free agency schedule look like
Not sure if it is legit but anyway it’s going to be an exciting, intensive and wild free agency and I’m glad that we have a front office that takes time to think before signing someone. But you can’t think too much either and let players go elsewhere.
BTW, a quick lesson of French: you can remove the “the” in “a la the Redskins” the la is kind of the French translation of “the”. It’s not a big deal, it’s just that I’m bored at work lol.
New York Giants French blog http://nygiantsfr.wordpress.com/ (with croissants and wine)
They move quickly when appropriate for them.
Think Rolle from last year.
Just get it done already...
I have the utmost confidence in our guys...
We’ll bring back AB because we’ve seen that he and Jacobs can be a devastating duo in the running game. We’ll keep Steve Smith because he’s one of the best possession WR’s in the NFL when healthy and I don’t think the Giants want to see someone else reap the benefits. Boss we’ll get on the cheap and if Kiwi is 100% cleared to return, we bring him back too.
As for outside guys I think it’s clear we should target an impact LB. A few names that are of interest to me are D’Qwell Jackson, Paul Posluszny, Ernie Sims, and Barrett Ruud. If we can get one or two of these guys I think we’ll solidify our LB corps to the point it won’t be our weakest position anymore.
I’d also like to see us bring in another solid KR/PR basically because we don’t know how the rookie will pan out. No matter what happens, it’s going to be a fun FA period.
Posluszny said that he wants to stay in Buffalo
Ruud or even McIntosh would be great for the Giants too.
New York Giants French blog http://nygiantsfr.wordpress.com/ (with croissants and wine)
As long as they keep AB and Smith, they'll be fine
those 2 are top priority, and not retaining them would be a big time failure. Kiwi may never be the same again, so if he’s not back its not a big deal unless he really is healthy. Cofield is pretty much gone unfortunately, hope Bro works out in St. Louis.
Osi’s situation will probably work out fine. He’ll be back and if healthy gets 10+ sacks no problem.
Last night, a comedian died in New York. Somebody knows why. Somebody knows
I wouldn’t mind McIntosh, Rudd is long in the tooth I think. There is another LB from GB I wouldn’t mind bringing on board. We shall see, like someone said: in Reese we be trusting!
Ruud is actually younger then McIntosh
Last night, a comedian died in New York. Somebody knows why. Somebody knows
Barely...
McIntosh November 15, 1982
Ruud May 20, 1983
Either way I’d be glad to have one of them play in blue.
Other potential FA that would look good in NY:
Tulloch (but he’s probably going to stay in Ten)
Posluszny (wants to say in Buffalo)
Anderson (I dunno but apparently he’ll stay in Charlotte)
Morrison: older but can do the job pretty well I think (at least he did in Oakland)
Bradley: not a flashy guy but I’d rather see him away from Philly
Session: a young tough guy who can find a way to make 10 tackles with a dislocated elbow. Injury prone though.
New York Giants French blog http://nygiantsfr.wordpress.com/ (with croissants and wine)
Quincy Black is another
Get Better, Not Bitter.
by BigBlueIntervention on Jul 11, 2011 4:18 PM EDT up reply actions
Damn
I always forget him ^^ you’re right.
New York Giants French blog http://nygiantsfr.wordpress.com/ (with croissants and wine)
alll goood
we’ve got plenty of options that won’t cost a fortune. Hopefully we jump on one of these guys.
Get Better, Not Bitter.
by BigBlueIntervention on Jul 11, 2011 4:35 PM EDT up reply actions
well if Ruud is long in the tooth
McIntosh is a walrus
Last night, a comedian died in New York. Somebody knows why. Somebody knows
well played
Get Better, Not Bitter.
by BigBlueIntervention on Jul 11, 2011 5:59 PM EDT up reply actions
from what i was reading about Morrison
he was extremely overrated coming out of Oak., and the Jags weren’t too thrilled about his play. i’m officially off the Morrison bandwagon.
Yes, I am a Giants fan. Now that we got that out of the way....
IMPEACH DOLAN!!!!
I will not - lose! -Jay Z-
The Giants have overpaid for free agents
And they’ve been doing it since 2008. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with admiting that. Because we now have something like the 4th highest payroll going into 2011 – without considering any free agents, including our own.
I believe Webster is set to make the highest of anyone on the team this year at just over $13 million. His base salary is $8 million, but he has some bonuses that kick in this year. You can say that we needed to re-sign him, and we did, but his cap number this year is going to hurt us when it comes time to sign free agents.
It continued with Boley, Bernard, and Canty. Canty is the only one, IMO, that can even be considered playing close to the level of the contract he signed. Bernard has to be the most expensive backup DT in the NFL, with the exception of that guy down in DC. Boley is being paid an awful lot to have almost no presence against the run.
Jacobs’ contract is another that has been something of an albatross since we signed him to the deal. Now, we almost have to restructure it.
Rolle is another one….The list goes on. My point is that Reese has been a little too loose with the wallet since the end of the 2008 season, and we have nothing to show for it since.
The NFL and NFLPA? They can kiss my ass, OK? They can line up and kiss my ass.
I totally hear you.
But this is completely normal when you are a big market team who plays the cap game near the cieling every year. There is always going to be decisions to be made. And often cap casualty type decisions. Like Ward after 2008. Or Brofield this year. But look at how often the Giants have signed great young players to good deals financially. Osi, Tuck, Snee were all signed to great deals as far as the team goes. And there are many more.
Just get it done already...
Well given the potential of a reduced salary cap this year
Reese is going to need to be smarter with giving out money this offseason. Go back to the days of 2007 and 2008, when we were finding guys that nobody wanted, like Kawika Mitchell, Madison Hedgecock, Domenik Hixon, Danny Clark, etc., and having them come in and be very good role players or at least solid starters.
This offseason is going to show us just how good some of these GMs are. There are “under-the-radar” guys all over the place out there to be signed. Reese has had time to find some of these types of players, so my hope is that he goes back to more of those kinds of signings.
The NFL and NFLPA? They can kiss my ass, OK? They can line up and kiss my ass.
That sounds good.
But what do you mean by “a reduced salary cap this year?” All indictions are that it will go up from the 2009 number. As it does every year based on revenues.
Just get it done already...
All I've heard
is a cap at around $120 million. The owners are trying to reduce the amount of revenue the players are getting, which would mean reduced player salaries (and therefore, reduced cap).
The NFL and NFLPA? They can kiss my ass, OK? They can line up and kiss my ass.

by 



























