Hakeem Nicks. (Photo by Otto Greule Jr/Getty Images)
Overrated: S Antrel Rolle. He's a solid player, but Pro Bowl player? Not quite. He got way too much hype last season.
Underrated: WR Hakeem Nicks. This kid is special. He had a huge season in 2010 and few noticed. They will in 2011.
What do you guys think? Give us your choices for most overrated and underrated Giants, and your rationale. And let's try to keep it friendly.