Which Giants Should Be Top 100 of 2011?

Lets see Demarcus Ware, Jay Ratliff…maybe Dez Bryant or Miles Austin, and well that’s really the only good players they have.

Snee should be on it along with Osi and Tuck. I have seen that Antrel Rolle is on the list, but I don’t feel like he belongs there.

I watched my first episode last night. I wasn’t paying full attention to it because it was not that compelling. Not like the top 100 of all-time series they had. That was great. Snee is on the list, in the 80’s, I believe. And Eli better be on that friggin’ list seeing how Josh Freeman was on there!

Side note: TC was the guy who spoke about Jay Ratliff, who was also in the 80"s.

I like your list. I think Rolle may be on there, maybe Matt Dodge, too (yeah right)

nicks should be too, but hell, most (being precautious, or if not all) of us) dont work for the guys that make these lists, so thats just what i think

I’d add Snee in there most def. I don’t think there’s a question he’s top 100.

McKenzie would probably be a "should be’ but probably won’t.

eli snee tuck osi rolle

The linebacking crew?

I’ll give you a hint it’s RHETT JESUSCRUSHING BOMAR

These air every Sunday, so we won’t know the end of the list until July 3rd.

71. Mario Williams
72. Tony Romo
73. Trent Cole
74. Greg Jennings
75. Jay Ratliff
76. Santonio Holmes
77. Chris Snee
78. Dallas Clark
79. D’Brickshaw Ferguson
80. Jared Allen
81. B.J. Raji
82. Lamarr Woodley
83. Mike Williams (Tampa)
84. Josh Cribbs
85. Jason Babin
86. Josh Freeman
87. Jordan Gross
88. Vernon Davis
89. Adrian Wilson
90. Joe Flacco
91. Terrell Owens
92. Lance Briggs
93. Eric Berry
94. Frank Gore
95. Jon Beason
96. Nick Collins
97. Shaun Phillips
98. Darren McFadden
99. Chad Clifton
100. Donovan McNabb

What in the hell? He shouldn’t have made the list at ALL. The worst season of his damn career. Struggled with accuracy and was missing wide open receivers all year for the skins. You can’t be serious

It doesn’t look like Eli is going to make the top 100 because there’s only 8 QBs to be left (said there was going to be 12 QBs on the top 100 i believe) so that has to leave probably vick, big ben, rivers, peyton, brees, brady, rodgers, and matt ryan. cant see eli making it over any of them given his unpopularity.

As for the Giants I’d put up there:

1. Tuck
2. Osi (well of 2010, he set the record for FFs, he deserves to be there)
3. Snee
4. McKenzie (well PFF claims hes the most dominant run blocking tackle in the NFL for months now and they love to gush about him)

Seeing how Mike Williams and supposedly 18 total WRs made the list… I really hope Nicks does make that list. Wishful thinking that Bradshaw is going to make the list. I wouldn’t be surprised if Rolle makes it just on reputation with the players

2007 wasn’t enough, prove ’em all wrong again. So I can say “told ya so”, again….

Is this the list of the 100 best going into the 2011 season or the 100 best from the past year?
Either way, if its true that only Tuck, Snee, Rolle are the only Giants on the list… then there is a problem. ROMO (played 6 games in 2010 before the Giants broke him), MCNABB (got replaced by Sexy Rexy)!!!!!! really… player and coaches, really?
Its sad, people are going to hate Eli for the rest of his life because of draft day. Prove them all wrong Easy E, win it all like 3 more times.

this should have been done is to break it up into positions. Top 10 QB’s, top 10 DE’s, etc. How can you look at #77, G Chris Snee and say he is a better or worse football player than #95, LB Jon Beason? Just doesn’t make sense to me in that regard.

For those wondering, Eli will not be in the list

http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2011/05/24/eli-mannings-peers-dont-think-hes-a-top-100-player/

And as always, the comments are just a bowl full of laughs. The fact that Flacco, Freeman and McNabb are on the list is just sickening.