Greg Jones Or Jacquian Williams? Who Do You Want On The Field?

I wanna see what Herzlich and Paysinger can do.

They all have talent, but they shine in different areas. Right now, Williams is more raw than JPP was a year ago. He’s just barely growing into his body, and he hasn’t played any more football.

How about they put them on the field when the situation best suits their abilities?

(I happen to agree with Jones, that its hard to find your groove when you’re coming off a 4 snap game)

While I like Williams ability, I’ll take a player who is close to being where he’s supposed to be and get help making the tackle. Instead of a player who is totally out of position and then needs to get bailed out by a CB or SS.

I think once Williams get some experience, he’ll take over for Jones.

Enough of this not being able to stop the run BS.

Throw MF Ty Sash in there on running downs as well.

In all fairness to Herz, it’s not an insult, and his athleticism is limited because of a battle with cancer (whereas Blackburn’s athleticism was limited at birth).

Blackburn was a player that made up for his lacking athleticism by always knowing where to be, limiting mental mistakes. I think Herz does the same.

I’d like to find out what he can really do, but right now, he might be doomed to special teams. But this might work out better for him. I can only imagine that the Giants don’t want to risk putting him out there on defense if he’s still a step too slow. Herz will be a long-term project. I’d rather wait until next season to see him get extensive reps, as an injury wouldn’t help the guy at all, given what he’s had to overcome recently.

was he benched on sunday?

i dont know why. i thought he may have actually done something wrong. i was at game and havent watched the replay. did he play at all?

For the next game — Williams.

With the Pats’ two big TE’s, and given JWill’s speed and size, Williams is going to have to cover one of them (Rolle on the other, CWeb on Walker and Ross on Branch). I see him getting a lot of snaps this week, and Jones not seeing as much time.

Against SF the following week, with Gore pounding the ball, maybe the reverse.

but what I do find a little concerning is the wild swings in number of snaps between the two of them. Just not sure what that says from a coaching standpoint. Zero snaps for Williams last week… I just have a hard time believing thats because of scheme or situation. Obviously they are very different players, and each has their strengths… it’d just seem advantageous to make sure they both see consistent playing time.

I think either or possibly both could be very good given a couple years.

Obvious…Jones running biased plays, Williams passing biased. Decide on play by play basis.

Depends who the team is. I do not think it is cut and dry for either.

Give Herz and Pay some snaps too where appropriate. TC, guys do not develop without playing.

Jones.

I honestly believe that the Pats are game planning to run all over us on Sunday. Obviously you worry about Brady and the TE’s in the passing game, but the Pats have been a very good running team this year, and we have been a VERY bad run stopping D. If we don’t stop the run, we lose. That means the early downs are extremely critical; we have to win on first down, and if that means sacrificing some speed to keep the better run stopping LB on the field, I say so be it. Our pass rush, which is the single biggest advantage we have in this game, will mean nothing if we can’t force New England into some 3rd and longs. Gotta win the early downs, and Jones gives us a better chance at doing that. No disrespect to Williams, who I really do like as a player. Just my opinion.

Need speed vs NE receivers. But neither is a MLB who can stop the run. Dont think Herz ready yet.

Bradshaw out of Sunday’s game. Cracked bone in his foot. Surgery possible. DAMN!

+ No Nicks = No Chance

I picked Jones..but I really like Williams speed..The coaches will pick the guy that has been most consistent in practice

Eli has excelled this year against the blitz

Can they be physically dominated? Have they been? I believe the answer to this question is the key to Sunday’s game. If our OLine can physically control NE DLine, we’ll be ok with Jacobs and Ware and a dash of Scott.

Did he get maliciousy screwed like me?..

Just watch the games, they make a couple of plays a game, but we need someone that is going to produce all of the time we need someone that is smart in the middle can play the run and pass. and these two are not it, look at the big running plays, they are no place to be found. time to give Herzilich a shot, smart player and can play all LB spots!!

He’s been making things happen. The running game has been a non-factor. I think Ware is gonna fit Sunday’s game plan better than BJ. We’re gonna need a guy who can CONSISTENTLY catch the ball out of the backfield. Can’t be dropping the ball with a wide open field like BJ did last week.

Speed Kills

jam him at the line…can match his speed…haha

just throwing out some crazy talk now…

but yea…he’s probably gonna have to cover hernandez this week