Daily NFL Draft Prospect Profile: Sam Young, OT, Notre Dame
[Remember to check the '2010 NFL Draft' section for all stories relating to the draft.]
How can we do this lengthy series of Daily NFL Draft Prospect Profiles and not once feature a player from Notre Dame? Can't do it, so today we fix that.
Of course, the Giants have no interest in quarterback Jimmy Clausen. And I doubt seriously we will see Golden Tate in a Giants uniform.
So, that leaves us with Sam Young, the mammoth (6-foot-8, 320-pound) right tackle. Young is a guy who started for four years at Notre Dame, but like most things connected to Fighting Irish football these days never quite lived up to what people thought he would become.
He is, however, a Notre Dame lineman and talented ND linemen always seem to find their way into the NFL. So, let's take a closer look.
Sam Young Scouting Reports
From Draft Countdown.
Great height and bulk with a huge frame ... Long arms ... Good natural strength ... Is capable of getting a big push in the run game ... Not a great athlete ... Isn't very quick or agile ... Has heavy feet ... Really struggles with speed ... Can only play one position.
Will likely be relegated to right tackle at the next level --- Never quite lived up to all the hype but is a battle-tested veteran with rare size and solid intangibles --- Didn't develop into the top prospect some envisioned early in his career but has the ability to be a serviceable pro and perhaps more in the right situation.
From the National Football Post.
Plays with a mean streak in the run game. He showcases good overall athleticism for a guy his size when asked to slide-block and get out in space. He exhibits the pop to create some movement off the ball. Young works hard to finish blocks but struggles to consistently keep his base down through the play ... Young gets a bit heavy-footed when asked to slide on contact and struggles to mirror his man. He allows defenders to easily sidestep and disengage from his block when they want to get physical and is only average when asked to reach the edge.
NFLDraftScout after watching Young at the Senior Bowl.
The highly touted prep athlete served as an effective pass blocker in Charlie Weis' pro-style offense. Despite operating exclusively at right tackle, his lack of foot quickness and flexibility was quickly exposed by the speed of Senior Bowl defensive ends this week. Even worse, at 6-8 he's too tall to move inside to guard.
Why Young fits with the Giants
Well, the Giants do need to find alternatives to the aging Kareem McKenzie on the right side. Think about it for a minute and Young is a bit like McKenzie -- a very good run blocker who is exposed by good pass-rushing defensive ends. Besides, is it possible for the guy to be less productive as an NFL player than Guy Whimper? I doubt it.
Why the Giants should pass
Because if the guy can't play tackle at the NFL level, and there is doubt he is athletic enough to do so, you would like to be able to move him to guard to take advantage of his run-blocking ability. His height and lack of athleticism make that pretty much impossible, though.
(E-mail Ed at bigblueview@gmail.com. Follow Big Blue View on Twitter.)
20 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Pass
This would appear to have only OL depth written all over it and any depth we get will have to be versatile enough to play more than one position. Besides, it looks like he’ll struggle at the next level.
Bleeding Blue since 1962
Agreed
If we are talking about a starter it’s one thing to peg a set spot, but for lineman depth I want versatility.
Love the ND guys
but unfortunatly this guy sounds like a no-go to me. can possibly be OK at the next level but with footwork being a major factor to how well you block, and this guy being a 4 year starter in a pro system and yet still cant get his footwork down, he doesnt sound very promisng to me. maybe a good O-line coach can get this guy NFL ready but who knows.
late late pick if anything
Lawyer: Peter, Sarah has decided to press sexual harrasssment charges against you.
Peter: Sarah...Is that the one we video taped taking a dump?
by Plaxico Burress on Mar 31, 2010 11:59 AM EDT reply actions
If we're going OL
I’d rather go with Eric Olsen.
Sam Young coming out of HS was the top OL recruit in all the land, or at least up there.
But like any not QB or WR from Notre Dame…the development of him was practically zilch.
I’d take a 7th round flier on him at least tho. The talent is there, and with the Giants OL coach, we could look at a steal?
Get HWSNBN...and they will come
Agreed!
I’m glad someone brought it up. Kyle Calloway has been my favorite right tackle prospect in this draft. He’s not a depth guy or a really athletic project with huge upside that needs development and time (I.E a William Beatty). Calloway is an established tackle who I feel can start on this line someday. He also plays on that Iowa offensive line, which is very well coached.
I wouldn’t be shocked if he sneaks into the late 2nd/early 3rd like Sebastian Volmer did for the Patriots, who I also liked last year but I am very happy with Beatty anyway
Apples to apples
The problem with a lot of the scouting reports on Young is that he was a college LT. So when they are labeling him as slow, that is comparison to guys like Okung. Calloway gets great press because he played RT in college and is expected to play RT in the pros. Young got good Senior Bowl reviews playing RT, and similar to what happens in the Pro Bowl, a lot of the defensive talent he went up against will be playing the right side in real games.
I like Calloway better because of the certainty factor, and think he’s a 3rd rounder. But if we do not address the o-line early, I think Young is a good pick later on (5th maybe). McKenzie still has one more year left on his contract. If Young does not look good, then we can address the position next year.
D. Ware swaps sides and rushes against McKenzie to take advantage of him. Is that really going to change because it is a different RT not good enough to pass protect?
McKenzie isn't that bad in pass protection
Yeah, he isn’t elite and sometimes requires help from TE’s and RB’s but when he is healthy he is better than average
by mclaren_is_the_best on Mar 31, 2010 4:23 PM EDT up reply actions
agreed
Most of the times, when he blows his assignments, it seems that he misses the snap count. He’s a better RT than most teams have.
All OLBs move around from time to time to change up the pass rush. But Ware was usually matched up against Diehl. As a recent LT convert, no one considers him good enough to move their best pass rushers away. And you still want your best guys on the blind side.
No doubt
you want your best guy on the blind side. Just pointing out that in the NFL RT can’t be a slouch on pass protection either.
Reminds me of Conrad Goody...Pass
"When I was a boy and had no sense I got my pecker stuck in an electric fence..Well it curled my hair and tickled my balls, and made me shit in my overalls"
Young could end up as a 6th round or later pick
Maybe UDFA,
After 5th round he isn’t bad. By that part of the draft you are looking at flawed players or players from small schools or projects.

by 


























