Season prediction for 2010-2011 season

way too early to comment.

I don’t see Giants recruiting anything more in the FA market until after the draft. Let’s see how that goes before we jump ahead of ourselves. Also, a lot depends on how injured players come back after an off-season break. Hold on to your predictions because you have first-call on bragging rights if they are even close at this stage.

one draft pick so that should and will help with depth issues. Since it is soooo early no one can really tell. On top of that you don’t factor in any growth for our young WR core. Who knows if we won’t get pressure by the front 7? Too many questions to make a judgement

PT- 2nd round pick, not worth it. Plus, NO would never let him go, it’s probably just a contract -bargaining thing.

Jevon Kearse- Our guys are essentially vets now, even Kiwi’s been playing for 4 years. What’s keeping Kearse from having a monster season? His age. Defensive end is a game for young guys (other than Strahan, but he’s future HOF). Kearse hasn’t been good in a looooong time.

Pisa- I love this guy, but unlike Boley and Goff who are heavier than their listed weight, Tinoisamoa struggles to maintain even 230… Don’t we have enough problems against the run?

DB’s- Slow and old and injury-prone. And frankly? None of them are very good.

WR’s- We have an awesome young corps of WR’s with plenty of depth. I refuse to imagine Coles as a Giant.

basically disagree with every player on here.

I totally agreed with your first graf. I think maybe ‘Spoon = McClain (duck and cover) but then again, I’m no talent scout and if one of those safeties is BPA or better than Spoon/McClain they could grab a S no problem. Hell even a DT.
Yet I totally disagree with your FA analysis.
I don’t think we need a running back. We have 5 serviceable backs: 2 starters, 2 backups, and a question mark in Brown.
Taking Kearse would be anathema to the Giants M.O. … I don’t see them picking up spent veterans. And I don’t see Chi failing to re-sign Pisoaisoeisoa … not to mention I think we’re ok at OLB with Boly, Sintim, and backups.

I’d be happy with Spoon or McClain in the 1st as 1 will be there… S or DT or OL most of the rest of the way depending on BPA…

11-5 was a safe comment above I’ll say 12-4 (3-0)

to make predictions like these especially since JR has proven he is very smart at drafting players. Also i think the only thing the giants need to rebuild is their additude. Last year they visably weren’t playing with the intensity they were in years before. I believe that will change this year bc Perry Fewell is said to be a very emotinal coach who will get the players fired up

Maybe…….MAYBE…..MAYBE, Pisa like 2-3 yrs ago

We obviously have some holes to fill and need depth in other areas, but I would say we are far from rebuilding. Every team has at least a weakness or 2. I think its hard to assess exactly because part of the problem was Sheridan and he has been replaced. Another problem was injuries…God willing we are healthy this year. If Osi, Tuck, and Kiwi return to form that will go along way. A great pass rush covers a lot of problems.

Prefer to build through the draft, get younger, not older and more injury prone. We have seen how injuries can derail a talented team in the past.

Injuries are a part of the game, but consider the Cowboys in ‘09. I believe Colombo missed a couple games(Doug Free came in and they didn’t miss a beat) but outside of him they were healthy the entire year. With a little luck(Ross, KP, Brown, etc. coming back strong) this is an elite team talent wise.

As far as predictions, I do believe the core talent on this team is still there. We really put a lot of stock in our dominant D-Line and down the stretch when they were ailing, we couldn’t make up for it.

I disagree with everything your saying except Sean Weatherspoon

Has the Cowboys winning 13 games next year. He cited that the Giants aren’t a good running team. In my furious rage I turned off the TV. Does Herm Edwards have any clue how banged up we were last year? Doubtful…

I don’t think we will be 3rd in the East, the Eagles are overrated and Eli managed to figure out their defense in the second game, the only problem is that Sheridan was possibly the worst DC ever hired, If they just stuck a corner on Jackson he won’t be burning us for 30yards per pop every drive. The cowboys were extremely lucky with injuries last year and their Oline will probably take another step back this year because of the age factor.

Also I don’t see a need for any of those FA pickups, they are all past it and I think were better off giving the chance to younger, stronger players.

I like Weatherspoon though, and agree that the giants aren’t going to be really good this unfortunately but neither will the other nfc east teams.

Alright let me clarify some things and try to redeem myself…Firstly, I obviously chose the wrong word when using “rebuilding” in my analysis. When I said that I had pretty much the defensive issues in mind and let that dictate my thoughts so that’s where that came from. I am sorry to offend by saying that and I very much do not believe the Giants are a rebuilding team such as St. Louis or Detroit. Secondly, my free agent anaylsis was just players I believe would give a little bolster to the roster, not KEY people we need nor should absolutely pursue. I hope you guys don’t hate me as much now that I explained myself a little but I just called it as i saw it as of now. I love the Giants with every bit of my being so I would enjoy not being the forum idiot.

… he says 1-15