Antonio Cromartie anyone?

…but if I were the Giants I’d do that deal yesterday.

if we’re talking about a safety and a pick..OK.

AC’s not a safety. An no..moving TT to safety isn’t an option.

AC’s not all that good anyway.

Jacobs for AC? not a chance. the bruiser needs to stay. he played all year on a f-ed up knee. it had to hurt to walk nevermind run over 300lb d-lineman. jacobs will be beastin people in 2010 like he has the past few years (except 2009 of course) CB isnt a real need for this team, with TT, Ross, C-Webb were fine.

Cromartie is overrated. He looked awful back in the 2008 season. He claims he was playing with a broken hip but it looks like to me he was exposed since the Chargers had lack of pressure on the QB that year.

any corner will look exposed with lack of pressure. just look in are own back yard.

But that isn’t too bad of a trade, if Cromartie’s ego allows him to play nickel then ok but for starting corners TT and Webster are miles better

look what was left in are secondary. 3 out of starters hurt and the fourth benched. that cant happen again. unless we are ok with giving up 400 + pionts.

Our CB’s are not really the problem. Cromartie’s no less injury prone then Aaron Ross…so I really don’t see the point of this.

Better off drafting a mid to low round CB and throwing him out there, like Trevard Lindley like was in the prospect profile yesterday.

Cromartie’s not that good and not getting any younger.

..really, this makes no sense.

If we’re trading for a player…why not trade for a need position such as S/MLB/DT?

And if we’re creating a gaping hole at RB…why are we not getting an extra pick back so we can fill that RB need?

it lets use do alot of things if hit buy the injury bug. is ross ok ?. is CW ok ? is KP ok? i dont like all the ?s

This is a no-brainer. Cromartie would come in and start with TT running the nickel. He is a big play waiting to happen, something our entire secondary sorely msses. As much as I love Jacobs, at this stage he is clearly not going to get any better, not to mention the value of a CB trumps the value of a RB. The NFL is a pass happy league now, we could never have enough cover guys.

This is a no-brainer. Cromartie would come in and start with TT running the nickel. He is a big play waiting to happen, something our entire secondary sorely msses. As much as I love Jacobs, at this stage he is clearly not going to get any better, not to mention the value of a CB trumps the value of a RB. The NFL is a pass happy league now, we could never have enough cover guys.

The Giants shouldn’t consider Cromartie because they don’t need him. It’s really that simple. You draft a CB in 2007 in the 1st round in Ross. You don’t give up on him because of one injury-plagued season. Bruce Johnson was an undrafted rookie. He got valuable playing time last year that he can build upon for the future. You draft a CB in 2008 in the 2nd round in Thomas. He had a great year. You have Webster, a 2nd round pick in 2005, who is still very good. Where are you going to put Cromartie, who will want to start?

There’s a reason why SD would like to trade him. He gave up more yards and more receptions than all of our CBs except for Dockery, who I don’t think will be back. He’s also really soft at tackling, especially against the run. He ranks behind the top 4 Giants CBs in that department. And a Tampa 2 CB needs to be a great tackler.

i dont get this trade it would suck for us Jacubs was one of the best backs in the league before this season and he has one bad year and everyone wants to toss him

So I watched a few of their games. AC is very overrated and injury prone. The only reason you think he’s a good pick is the one good season he had which would be now 3 seasons ago. He has played nowhere close to the level he displayed in the 07-08 season. Whether you think it or not, Brandon Jacobs is very important to the Giants getting back to Giants Football. We are built to run the ball. But with our top two tandem injured along with the issues along the line forced us to adjust into a passing team, as well as playing from behind. A healthy Jacobs and Bradshaw would have been effective. They weren’t and neither were we. The Cowpokes did not have a single player on IR going into the playoffs. Team health can destroy any teams chances.

I think Antonio Cromartie is overrated, so I’d be baffled if JR actually made this horrible move

don’t forget he was also a rookie and there wasn’t much in the way of a pass rush this year. Even if he is the nickel corner for us next year (which will happen only if they move Ross to safety full time) I think that our corner depth is still very good.

I think Aaron Ross should be moved to safety because IMO he’s not durable enough for one of the cornerback spots, I say we get rid of c. c. brown and move ross into the SS position and we see how Kenny Phillips comes back from his injury … I still think Brandon Jacobs is very valuable to this team, like a lot of people were saying, he’s a bruiser who wears down the opposing defense, so I wouldn’t get rid of him