While some have made comparisons to Peyton, Brees and Palmer, let's not forget that Eli is the highest paid QB among them. As the highest paid QB, you should not have the highest amount of picks. Add to that, he has 5 fumbles lost this year - including his infamous head first dive (which coincidentally he did back in 2008 against the Eagles).
Whatever he did in the past, he got paid for. Start earning the current paycheck consistently!! Eli can win or lose games for the Giants. The 3 points the Vikings got yesterday were on Eli - not the defense.