Who do you prefer to play against Stafford or Hill?

Stafford’s probably rusty and still not 100%.

Either way, a QB wearing powder blue’s gonna get messed up next weekend.

He’s got so much potential as our starting quarterback, despite the injury issues, he’s got the arm to throw 60+ yards on his back foot. There’s a reason the Madden games have him as the guy with the most throwing power, he has a lot of it. Hill is a good back-up though, so don’t expect the Lions offense to be stagnant, but I anticipate a close game with a Giants win at the end.

I have a great deal of respect for Stafford though, once he gets an O-line that is’t gonna get him killed, I think he is going to be one of the better QB’s in the league. The kid has a desire to win. I forget who they were playing last year but Stafford could barely even stand and still threw a last second game winning TD. I think the city of Detroit developed a nasty man-crush on thier QB that day.

That game was the defining moment of the kind of franchise quarterback Matthew Stafford could turn into. He got hurt, came back in and threw his 5th touchdown pass for the win and had over 420 yards. He owns the NFL record for the youngest starting quarterback to throw for 5 TDs and over 400 yards in a single game. He is only 22 years old but he is probably the smartest quarterback we’ve had since…I really can’t think of the last time I thought that. His football i.q is extremely high, which is part of the reason he was drafted #1 overall in 2009. He is football smart and has a powerful arm and is a great leader. I’m excited for the kind of quarterback he could be once he get’s back and stays healthy. This year the Lions actually have weapons to use besides Calvin Johnson so it will be fun to watch this year.

This isn’t Vick vs. Klob. Stafford’s got the elite passing qualities but he takes too many big hits…if I were the Lions I wouldn’t bring him back too early, the Giants destroyed 3 QBs this season already. Even if he was healthy its not like he’s Matt Schaub or even at that point Jay Cutler

Hill’s a solid backup, but he’s a backup for a reason. And of course, the Giants aren’t the Rams.

But only because I think coming off his injury he might be below par. Theres no doubt in my mind that Stafford is the better QB in Detroit though, so if he wasnt coming back from injury I’d prefer to play Hill.

He is superior to Hill but he’s GOT to be rusty whereas Hill is really groovin’.

Yet I think the Lions need to get him back in because he is the future. If I was the Lions I’d also consider not pushing him this particular week because the Giants D-Line is known to concuss a motherf$%^&*