Scouting the mock drafts

Brain Price!

McClain, Price, Williams and Thomas.. Wouldn’t be mad with either pick and then of course there are wildcards like someone I thought would be off the board or if we do trade Osi…

Are pretty much useless. Afterall, 2 out of those 9 above had the same pick, but the rest were all different. I said it before, there are a few teams that can or will influence who we may be able to take. Hopefully a team or two will mix it up and take someone off the radar.

In 1986 after winning the SB the Giants went D with their first six picks, inc Pepper Johnson.

D wins championships

Unless a phenominal athlete drops in their lap, JR should go heavy on D early.

Dunlap lazy, Spikes is overhyped and Jermaine Gresham?

I like all the others tho. Anthony Davis…I’d love to see him fall. As the Giants RT.

I like the idea of going D early and often…but you just don’t ignore spots on the team.

BPA, but modified (like last year with Nicks) is probably the best idea.

If they think Anthony Davis is gonna be a dominant RT for the next 10, then why not? Or if Davis falls…I think there’d be a ton of teams they could hold him hostage for and get some team to overspend.

is the best safety in the draft. There is some debate on whether Mays or Thomas is 2nd best.

So are the best two safeties in the draft, Earl Thomas (Texas) and Taylor Mays (USC)….

He’s athletic but he’s not much of a run stopper. I think Dan Williams is the better choice.

Your absolutely right, if Rolando McClain is available at the 15 spot or anywhere from11-15 we should trade up and get him, He is the smartest player in college football and is an emense athletic and physical prescence. bringing him in will fill in for what pierce brought to the table as far as being an on field coach! and if you couple that with his patrick willis like physical prescence on the field he would definetly be the pick here if it were up to me…… the only other two i would consider over him if they were still available between 11-15 would be Eric Berry and Suh! but that would be highly unlikely but things happen.

Osi is signed for 2 more years and is 28-years-old. The Raiders traded a 2011 1st for 30-year-old Richard Seymour and Seymour is a free agent.

I would trade Osi for a 2nd and a 4th, I also definetly would sign richard seymour and release Rocky bernard, seymour can play DT or LE in a 4-3 and would be able to be an every down payer who still is great and a very vocal leader, Seymour-McClain- a healthy Kenny Philips- a SS like cam Chancelor from V-tech in the 2nd-3rd round and i think that could be the base of another great off season for Jerry Reese.

I definetly would not use pick 15 on a DB unless it is berry safties like cam chancelor and Myron Rolle who was slated to be a high pick last yr if he didnt win the rhodes scholarship will still be available, but he would be an excellent 2nd or 3rd round pick 1st round has to be a MLB.

Kam Chancelor was just an example. we have the sideline to sideline safety in philips if healthy but Rouse is no where as much a big hitter that Kam is, he would be the prototypical SS in fewell scheme but like i said there is Myron rolle and some other guys out there that will be available later.

Chancelor is the prototype SS for what perry fewell likes to do with his safeies, he plays single high so that means KP will be the single high at FS and the SS will spend most of his time in the box, Chancelor would excel at this position as that was his strength in college, and again if it isnt berry i would go LB i love earl thomas as well but Berry or LB at that spot for me.

My point is we cannot pass up on McClain if he is there, i think he is a DC dream especially at MLB

Your right about that he will be available in the later rounds, but forget Kam i really hope we steal myron rolle, he would be an excellent pick up in round 2 or 3

I am generally against drafting safeties incredibly early. Unless they are a special player. Some of the better safeties of the last 15 years Darren Sharper, John Lynch, Bob Sanders were drafted outside of the first round. Obviously if Eric Berry is still on the board then take him but i’d rather get a safety in FA like Bethea.
I’m a firm believer in George Young’s “Planet Theory.” For those of you unfamiliar, basically there are a limited number of massive men (320+ in todays game) with the ability to be great and you must scoop them up when you get the chance. If there is a good defensive tackle available at this point it would be worth it to take him.

I know the Giants have to rebuild the Linebacking corp and a a corner, but if CJ Spiller is available at 15 I hope they take him. He’ll be a bigger game breaker in the Pros than Reggie Bush ever thought of being.

I mean seriously he has the worst mock skills!I think alot of times when people do their mocks they get it in their heads that certain teams would best have certain needs filled by specific players and kinda has that influence them to have high rated players mysteriously drop and it is so unrealistic to do it that way….and way unprofessional!SUCH AS MCLAIN SPILLER AND WHOEVER ELSE ALL FALLING!!!Hopefully it works and he GMEN get Mclain.BUt really doesnt seem poss. at 15.I’m all for Price or DWill anyway.Even O-line.

I’d even rather have O-Line

And I’m sure many others. I would get Darren Sharper AND draft a S within the first 2 rounds. If KP does come back he prob wont be 100% or close to that until 2011 if ever. George Wilson would be a nice pickup, I believe he is a FA, wouldnt cost alot, and has experience with Fewell’s system.

I dont have a problem drafting a S at 15 at all, as long as it’s the BPA. I would never reach for a S at 15, but its not good to reach for a player at any position. Earl Thomas at #15 would be great, especially if he can learn from Darren Sharper.