David Carr for starting QB!!!!!!

A $100 million clipboard holder? Where can I sign up?

NO

Carr chucked up a pass that Nicks made a play on….the other TD was a great read by both Nicks and Carr but let’s be real…the ball was almost overthrown and Nicks did all the work.

Also Smith dropped a sure fire TD from Manning. Not Eli’s fault.

But please keep this in mind that the game vs the jets was the first time we’ve actually had the chance to see this offense operate. It’s clear Eli and Manningham need more time together…and we haven’t even found out which WR’s will be cut and who will stay.

I know Eli had a tendency to throw high….but Eli also has a tendency to put the ball right on the money. The SB run in ‘07 proved it. I mean he out played Garcia, Romo, Favre, and Brady. If that was luck…well that’s some string of luck. He threw 1 INT and that shoulda been caught by Smith.

I’m not living in the past either…i know in NY the mentality is “what have you done for me lately” but we can not justify starting Carr after 1 good pre season game.

Also, I know Carr can keep plays alive with his feet…Eli flat out can not. At the same time Carr can kill plays with his feet…the Jets game was an improvement but in the past he’s had a tendency to leave the pocket early…or stay in the pocket too long.

to be honest with you, I don’t even know why I even put this much effort into this post because IMO it’s a no brainer, a non issue, an open and shut decision…Eli is the starter.

I like Carr as a backup QB, one who I believe is capable of stepping up in case of injury to Eli better than your typical backup. However, this article seems like it was purposely made for the reaction of people who take this post serious. If that isn’t the case, then may I suggest you just not post such topics anymore. Eli is better than Carr on way too many levels that shouldn’t even require explanation.

This must be the new login id of "Dave from Asheville"

Funny people actually entertain this hilarious post, by trying to justfiy why he is wrong. Clearly a joke….carry on.

out of respect for BBV.

But simply: you are wrong. While its debatable if Eli’s worth his contract, he’s definitely a franchise QB, something David Carr will never be.

Eli with the help of his teammates won the SB in 07, but tell me one single QB in the history of the game that didn’t have a good team beside him that won a SB?

Could other QB’s have done what Eli did in 07? Maybe. But they didn’t. The Giants D was great, but so was Dallas’, Green Bay’s and New England’s defenses. All very very good and rated just as high or higher than the Giants at some point in teh season.

…..and Eli beat all of them. Not the running game which was absent the whole playoffs, but Eli. Eli drove them down the field constantly.

If you want David Carr as you’re QB, fine. But remove the diehard fan from yourself cuz whoever STILL DOESN’T BELIEVE IN ELI after what this man has brought us already, DOESN’T DESERVE TO BE A GIANTS FAN!

…guess I ranted a little, but Im sure others would have done the same with Phil Simms, all of whom’s records will be broken by Eli sooner rather than later.

I doubt it.

Rhett Bomar park his car like a seasoned valet during training camp. Must mean that Eli can’t drive.

You cannot seriously believe what you just posted do you? David “Itchy Feet” Carr? Chris Palmer is still trying to undo all the bad habits from his stint at Houston all those years ago. Now you’re just going to hand him the reigns to a contending team after 2 meaningless preseason loses? I am not sure you are indeed a Giants Fan or a guy just getting a rise out of this board.

 enough said!

manning by a landslide. carr has very happy feet.

I hope you drink your coffee way to fast this morning and burn your tongue.

David Carr’s mom is posting at this site under a fake name!

Do you even remember 2007? Better yet, did you even watch?

If you did, there would be no way in hell you could even start this conversation.

Forget about the fact Eli has never missed the playoffs since taking over the starting job. Forget about that fact that Eli has never thrown for less than 20+ TDs or 3200+ YDs in a single season. Forget about the fact that he is a Pro Bowler and is everything you could ask for as far as on field demeanor and general work ethic and attitude goes.

Forget about ALL of that, and just remember what happened in the ‘07 Super Bowl…150+ Yards and 2 go ahead touchdowns in the fourth quarter alone. Only Joe Montana can also say he’s had such a quarter, in the biggest quarter, in the biggest game.

If that’s not good enough for the Giants, than what are you looking for?

but my feeling is that, if worse comes to worse and Eli gets hurt, Carr could have a really good season. I think behind the Giants O-line and with the Giants run game, Carr could really shine, and play himself into a big contract next year. It’s just a gut feeling I have about the guy, and I’ve been impressed with him in limited action. That said, there’s no way in hell he’s better than Eli at the important stuff, which is winning football games. The thought of benching Eli for Carr is so beyond ridiculous that I can only assume this post was a joke or was written by David Carr himself.

it was guaranteed 50+ comments.

did you forget about the superbowl and Eli MVP performance and oh hit big contract – no chance you will see Carr start unless ELi is hurt

the only thing can say is u r not a giants fan period. real giants fans remember life b4 eli, and guess wat buddy. HE HAS’NT MISSED THE PLAYOFFS YET!!!! now who’s the last giant qb that can make that claim? if u r really a giants fan u should never ever b allowed anywhere near our stadium ever again!!!!! have a nice day

you have officially lost you mind!!

Bka David Carr.