Now, I know not everyone who reads this blog plays Madden (I'm curious about the age distribution of this website's frequenters), but I think the ratings are interesting regardless:
I think they over estimate the speed of a couple players, namely, Ahmad Bradshaw and Clint Sintim. Bradshaw is 'quick', but I wouldn't say he has that much straight line speed. He only ran a 4.6 or something at the combine (yes, yes, I remember his run against Buffalo, but still, he's not the fastest guy on the team). Likewise, Sintim isn't known as a burner. He ran a 4.80 @ the combine, whereas a Ramses Barden ran a sub 4.6, yet Madden rated Sintim as faster than Barden
Are Jonathon Goff and Chase Blackburn really the two worst players on the team?
Also, is it just me or does David Carr get no love? I really think he is atleast a marginal starer in the league. He's no Peyton Manning, but if he started on a team other than the Texans I believe he would be a top 30 QB (he wouldn't be the worst right?).
Anyway, nothing important, I just thought it was an interesing topic of debate.
Who's the best player on the Giants?
Brandon Jacobs (20 votes)
Eli Manning (17 votes)
Chris Snee (19 votes)
Justin Tuck (58 votes)
Osi Umenyiora (25 votes)
Corey Webster (4 votes)
Other (2 votes)
145 total votes