Who should return kickoffs for the New York Giants?
Ahmad Bradshaw has handled the majority of the kickoff returns duties for the Giants the past two seasons. (via nymaniac)
The other day we looked at who should return punts for our New York Giants. Now, let's look at who should return kickoffs.
Here, I feel the same way as I did with punt returns. Domenik Hixon is clearly the best man for the job. He averages 29.3 yards per return for his career and is a threat to score every time the ball nestles in his waiting arms.
But, it is clearly unfair to ask him to do it full time since he will be such a key part of the offense.
The only scenario in which I see Hixon returning full time is if some combination of Mario Manningham, Hakeem Nicks, Sinorice Moss and Ramses Barden are so impressive Hixon can't get on the field next to Steve Smith.
Unfortunately for the return game, I think Hixon is too good of a receiver to let that happen.
So, if it isn't going to be Hixon returning kickoffs then who will it be? Let's look at the candidates.
Ahmad Bradshaw -- Obviously, Bradshaw can do this job. He has returned 77 kickoffs the past two seasons and is adequate. He just is nowhere near the breakaway threat Hixon is, and his 23.2 yards per return average shows that. I can live with him back there, but his lack of elite speed makes him less than an ideal kickoff returner.
Sinorice Moss -- Has the kind of speed you would love to see in a kickoff return guy, and the role makes sense if he is only the fourth or fifth wide receiver. Moss, though, has had two cracks at this job (a few games in both 2006 and 2008) and has yet to flourish. He averages just 20.2 yards per return, and has never broken a big one. Still, I would not be stunned if he is the guy. Tom Coughlin does like veterans (believe it or not, that's what Moss is now) handling the ball in those roles.
Danny Ware -- Could very well be the third running back for the Giants, and that makes him a candidate for this role. Derrick Ward did it when he was the No. 3 running back. Ahmad Bradshaw has done it for two seasons as the third back. Seems like it's been kind of a rite of a passage. Besides, Ware showed in the 2008 preseason that he might actually flourish in this role.
Andre Brown -- Same story for Brown. He might be the third back, and the kick return duties with the Giants sometimes seem to go along with that. The rookie did return some kicks at North Carolina State, but averaged only 201.1 yards on 17 career returns. So, this does not seem like an idea role for him.
DeAndre Wright -- The sixth-round draft pick was a collegiate return man, and I'm sure he will get a look. To make this crowded Giants' roster he will have to contribute on special teams, and this might be how.
8 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Brandon Jacobs
I felt the same way about Dayne when he was here. He may not take it to the house ever, but you’ll start at the 35 everytime. Obviously injury concerns makes this unfeasible though. Actually his rookie year, he played as the short man and ran a few, and sure enough, got out there, made contact and went down ten yards later.
One more thing
I saw Sinorice return a few last year, he’s so damn fast, he seem like a good bet, but I wanted to remind everyone there’s no more wedges this year on returns. Not sure if that might factor into the personnel you would use.
Wedge
That will be interesting to see. One fear is that it will expose the return men to some bigger hits. We will have to see. I always hated to see that wedge, with three guys running over one at full speed.
by Ed Valentine on Jul 21, 2009 5:07 PM EDT up reply actions
I swear this is the last unsolicited comment
No way does TC let Bradshaw near that ball with the fumbling issues he’s had. Willie Ponder was leading the league in return average, and he put one on the turf and was off the team.
Bradshaw
Has been the primary return guy for two years. I don’t think he’s got fumbling ‘problems.’ He’s lost a couple, but I actually do think TC trusts him.
by Ed Valentine on Jul 21, 2009 5:08 PM EDT up reply actions
Id rather not see Bradshaw
on kickoffs again.
I think it actually hurt him in that they didn’t let him carry the ball too much to keep him fresh for kickoffs.
Id rather him be that speed guy as the #2 back
by FreeBradshaw on Jul 22, 2009 8:16 AM EDT up reply actions
DeAndre Wright
and/or Moss would be nice. Id like to see the Giants get SOMETHING out of the former 2nd round pick, if he gets beat out for the 3rd WR spot KR would be nice.
ANd I like it when 6th and/or 7th rounders like Wright make the team. If he makes it as a kick returner, it will give him time to possibly work on his CB skills. Maybe in a few years time since he sticks around from special teams he becomes another late round gem for Reese?

by 

































