The Glory Game: How the 1958 NFL Championship Changed Football Forever: Review
If you've never read a story or caught a highlight film of "The Greatest Game Ever Played", the 1958 NFL Championship Game between the Giants and Colts, you'd probably think it was a classic well-played battle between two teams who stood toe-to-toe at the 50-yard line and slugged it out.
When you read "The Glory Game: How the 1958 NFL Championship Changed Football Forever" by Frank Gifford, you'll realize that was anything but true. Giff refers to the first two quarters as "the worst half of football we'd played all year", and when you hear him tell it, you'd be hard pressed to argue with him. The game is broken down almost play by play here, and Giant fans of all ages will be amused to hear of the Giants struggles to score points in those days and their need for the defense to keep them in the game. (sound familiar?)
"Glory Game" is a book Gifford never intended to write. He was originally contacted by author David Halberstam, who informed Gifford that he would be writing a book on the 1958 game, and would like to meet with Frank and get his insight. Unfortunately, David was killed in a car accident in April 2007, and Gifford decided to write the book as a tribute to David as well as the players in that famous 1958 game.
Gifford does a wonderful job of describing what it was like to be a New York Giant in the days before agents, major endorsement deals, and ESPN. It's an amazing look inside the life of an NFL player before they were millionaires.
While it is impossible to spoil the end of this story, since there probably isn't a football fan alive who hasn't seen the video of Alan Ameche scoring the winning touchdown, I can tell you that the storytelling is so well done, you'll find yourself getting caught up in it, and actually forgetting that the Giants lost this game.
Giff manages to capture the thoughts of many of the players from both teams who are still with us. Pat Summerall, Sam Huff, Art Donovan, Alex Webster, and Ray Berry are just some of the particpants in this book, and some of the stories you've probably heard before, but in this book they manage to still sound fresh.
There are some surprises in this book, at least for me. I don't want to spoil any of them, but I can tell you that one of them involves Vince Lombardi, and his disappointment at not getting the only coaching job he ever wanted.
Giff also does wonderful tributes to Giant QB Charlie Conerly, and RB Kyle Rote, two of his closest friends.
Whether you are a Giants fan who was around in those days, or if you've read this review and said "Who the heck is that?" a half-dozen times, give this book a read, you won't be disappointed.
Jim
0 recs |
8 comments
|
Comments
A bit off topic
but when Gifford tries to debunk the perception of this being a well-played game, it reminds me of an interview with David Gilmore from Pink Floyd. One of the members said they would do a concert and the performance was horrible by their standards, but inevitably a fan would come up to them afterward and say “Man, that concert was awesome!” Gilmore would think “What the (bleep) do you know?! It was crap.” At the time the band felt complete disdain for the audience because they couldn’t tell the difference. I wonder if some of the players involved on both sides of this game have felt the same way, as if to say “You never played, how would you know whether it was a good game?”
by rzor on Jun 11, 2009 10:01 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Sounds like a good read
I read a lot of books, but for some reason never read anything about/by my favorite teams. I’ve been meaning to start, so maybe I’ll start here (although I’ve been wanting to read Ralph V’s book on Eli too).
by potroast on Jun 11, 2009 12:15 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Bought this for my Dad for Father's Day
This was the first game he saw on TV up here in Canada, and he cheered the Giants as they shared players with the Montreal Allouettes of the CFL.
by brisulph on Jun 11, 2009 12:16 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Before the game,
pro football trailed baseball, boxing, college and pro basketball, college football and hockey, in the few American few cities where the NHL had teams I believe it was the first nationally televised NFL game. Millions watched pro footbal for the first time, It was a see-saw game and Unitas’s engineering of the last minute drive was heroic. The game was the spark that fired interest in the NFL, which grew over the years into the most popular sports entertainment in the country.
What was maddening to me was that theGiants could easily have won as they could have won all but one of the championship games they played in those days, Particularly, the ones where their aerial circus under YA(easily the best Big Blue QB IMO) was sabotaged by gale force winds and the one vs. the Bears when his knee was torn up on a play that would be illegal today (as were many others.). Since then, the Giants have never tried to be a pass-oriented offense
by blue gonz on Jun 11, 2009 12:28 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Tittle to Shofner
That was a thing of beauty during that glorious 3 year run at the beginning of the sixties.
Tittle could really throw that long strike down the sideline.
by Tucker Fredrickson on Jun 11, 2009 1:41 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Amazingly accurate passer
Great arm. As good as anyone who ever played the game When he retired, he had set a bunch of records. Remember, they played far fewer games in those days.
Adding to my first posting: What was so dramatic about Unitas was that he had been cut by the Steelers in his first training camp, played a year of sandlot and was hired by Weeb Ewbank (the guy who coached the Jets to the first AFL SB win) to back up George Shaw(I think) who went down for the year early in the season. Unitas was a rookie unknown to the vast majority who saw the game.
by blue gonz on Jun 11, 2009 2:38 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Weeb Ewbank
you almost never hear about him when people talk about all-time great coaches, but he won the two most transformative games in NFL history. I don’t really know enough about him as a coach to know whether the Colts or Jets could have won those games with other coaches, but you’ve gotta give the guy some credit for, at the very least, being in the right place at the right time – twice.
by cjmulrain on Jun 11, 2009 4:36 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
When Namath got to the Jets,
he made unfavorable comments re Weeb vs his college coach, Bear Bryant. Now, he can’t say enough good things about Weeb. Dick Vermeil married Weeb’s daughter
by blue gonz on Jun 11, 2009 4:45 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs

by 
















