I generally hate off-season rankings -- player rankings, team power rankings, whatever. That said, in the dead of the off-season long before training camp begins they at least give us something to talk about.
With all of that soapbox preamble aside, it brings me to my point. The Sporting News (yes, The Sporting News still exists!) has come out with its position-by-position NFL player rankings, courtesy of something called 'Real Scouts.'
Plaxico Burress and Amani Toomer are gone, and we're not sure he will have a go-to receiver in '09. If they are relying on rookie Hakeem Nicks, Manning is in trouble. Elite quarterbacks can carry teams on their back, but Manning failed last year when Burress and Brandon Jacobs got hurt. The Super Bowl 42 win was great, but this is a what-have-you-done-for-me-lately league.
Actually, I am perfectly fine with this ranking. It puts Eli just behind Donovan McNabb and Kurt Warner, and just ahead of Tony Romo. You can quibble over who goes where in that group, but at least Eli is finally getting recognition as a top 10 guy.
According to TSN, here is how the Giants stack up at some of the other positions.
- Brandon Jacobs is ranked third among running backs, behind only Adrian Peterson and Steven Jackson.
- Shaun O'Hara is ranked fourth among centers.
- Chris Snee is ranked as the second-best guard in the league, behind only Steve Hutchinson of the Vikings.
- Madison Hedgecock is ranked sixth among fullbacks.
- Osi Umenyiora is ranked seventh and Justin Tuck eighth among defensive ends. I will say two things about this. First, no way there are seven defensive ends better than Tuck. Second, I still maintain that Tuck is a better player than Umenyiora.
- In the defensive tackle rankings, new Giants Chris Canty (fifth) and Rocky Bernard (17th) get lots of love from TSN. Holdover Fred Robbins didn't even get a mention, which I think is too bad. I also think the Canty ranking is intriguing because he has never played inside.
- Michael Boley, the free-agent outside linebacker, is ranked 16th at that position.
- Antonio Pierce is ranked 11th among middle linebackers.
Again, none of this really proves anything. I am sure, though, that you guys have some thoughts on these.