UNCOORDINATED COORDINATORS

they shouldn’t……. We have the most predictable offense in the league. Eli’s efforts and the talent of the oline is the only reason why we’re not dead last in points / ypg

I agree. Although with Sheridan, it’s hard to tell whether he’s that bad or Spags was that good. I think most of us will agree that Spags was an amazing DC, and anyone’s going to struggle to reproduce the kind of success he had. Maybe our defense isn’t that talented, and was merely the beneficiary of a defensive mastermind. Then again, maybe Sheridan is simply not a good coordinator; it’s hard to tell.

As for Gilbride, I’ve made my position pretty clear. He does a lot of good things between the 20’s, but our persistent lack of success in the red-zone and in crucial short-yardage situations is very frustrating, and for this I think Gilbride is first to blame (though by no means entirely responsible). I asked this the other day, and I’ll ask again, what do you guys think of Charlie Weis as our OC? He’s been a very successful OC in the NFL and he’s got a history with the Giants.

Also, to be honest, I don’t think TC has done a good job this year. He’s never been a master schemer, but you expect his teams to be tough and disciplined, and this team is neither. It is well documented that Coughlin relaxed his iron-fist approach to coaching, and the Giants responded with a championship season. Now, however, I wonder if Coughlin has softened his edge too much.; it seems pretty apparent to me that the Giants have lost their hard-nosed identity. Should one mediocre season be enough to put TC on the hot-seat after two great seasons? Of course not. That being said, I’d love to see more of the old, fire-and-brimstone Coughlin in the future.

You knew we were in trouble when Eli is calling a timeout 30 seconds into game. Doesnt Gilbride have at least 2 plays ready ? He takes 35 of the 40 seconds it seems to get in the play and all I do is yell snap the f***ing ball already at the TV. Oh look another delay of game penalty…unbelievable.

To no avail, Even though I swear a monkey could run the offense better than Gilbride. Mainly we are too predictable on offense. 2nd and long and here comes the screen…3rd and short here comes the bomb. We all know, and if we as fans know then I sure as hell guarentee you the opposing coaches know what plays we are going to run out of specific packages. As far as Sheridan goes, well with how much talent he has to work with he does not deserve a shot next season. Sorry man but you gotta steal a game somewhere and all you’ve done is give em away like free popcorn.