I know stats so not tell the whole story, but I think there are some interesting pieces to think about here. Blue Gonz made the statement that Eli would never be as good a QB as Eli. This is not something the stats tell other than Eli is much better a taking care of the ball which has resulted in more playoff appearances than Warner. Comp pct, yds and TDs are certainly in Kurt's favor, but on a great Rams Team, I don't think they made the playoffs 3 of his 5 years leading that team. And they had Marshall Faulk nad a core of excellent receivers when playing in one of the worst divisions in football history (outside of the 80s/early 90s run for SF).