Big Blue View: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Fedor vs Rogers Results and Live Coverage

Looking at "the Greatest Football Game in History"

Mark Bowden is a writer working on a book about the 1957 championship game between the Giants and the Colts.  He sat down with Andy Reid to watch the game tape.  Reid had never before seen the tape

In an article in the Atlantic called Distant Replay, Bowden talks about Reid's analysis of the game and some of the key plays

The game as it was played in 1958 “is still an entertaining sport to watch, but it’s just not near as complicated,

The article is a pretty interesting read and offers a little insight on some of the players.  For example, at one point he sees

 

“‘Okay,’ the Colts are saying, ‘this guy, number 45 [Tunnell], is getting tight, and he was very aggressive on the last play, so we’ll sell a hard fake,’” Reid speculated. The Colts would set up as if they were going with another running play, he predicted, with the tight end, Jim Mutscheller, “coming up and out like he is going to crack” Tunnell with a block, but instead going past him up the field. “Then they should try and get [a pass] over the top to Mutscheller.”

On third down, Mutscheller moved just as Reid had suggested, faking a block on Tunnell and racing up the hash marks. Unitas faked the handoff and dropped back, looking downfield toward his tight end.

“But this guy [Tunnell] sniffs it out!” Reid said, impressed, watching as the safety turned and matched the tight end stride for stride. Unitas, harried suddenly by the Giants’ blitzing right cornerback, instead hurried a throw to Moore—“his safety valve,” said Reid—that was almost intercepted.

 

Reid sees similarities to today's game.  For example, the 4-3 defense. 

 

Reid recognized one Colts offensive formation as “the one we run the most—two receivers, two backs, and a tight end.” And he even noticed some of his own plays in the mix. “Look, this is a rattler route,” he said, watching Raymond Berry twist his way into the backfield, turning the Giants cornerback completely around and gaining a step.

The big differences?  The size and speed of the players, and the complexity of the game. 

The average player on the 1958 Colts starting team weighed 222 pounds. The average weight of a 2007 Indianapolis Colts starter was 243 pounds.

 

Towards the end of the game

 

At this point, Reid had become a rapt spectator.

“This is just simple football right now, man,” he said.

It's an interesting article if you have a chance

 

FanPosts are written by community members. This is simply a way for community members to express opinions too long to be contained in a comment.

0 recs  |  Comment 19 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Ha.

Yeah, I started getting it years ago when they were running a series about the clean-up at the WTC site. I’ve been getting it ever since then…although I’m not sure what point there is in subscribing anymore, since they make the whole issue available over the web.

by drunkUncle on Sep 14, 2008 11:06 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Actually by today's standards

the game was good but not spectacular. At least that’s my opinion. The fact that it went into overtime was exciting but the actual game winning play was predictable and nearly inevitable. Of course I was only 12 when I watched the game so my analysis by memory is a little vague.

 A lot of people forget that Baltimore was a much better team that year than the Giants and it is a credit to the G-men that they almost won.

by giant fan since 57 on Sep 13, 2008 6:59 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Thanks NYER

Fascinating to read the analysis of a great modern coach re that great game. I believe it’s called the greatest game ever played not just because of the action on the field (although Unitas was fantastic) but because it was the game that first drew the attention of the greater American public toward the NFL. I remember a championship game in the forties played by the Giants that drew only 7,000 fans. Before that game, college football and basketball, baseball, boxing, pro basketball, and even pro hockey in the few cities in which it was played, was more popular than pro football. Now pro football is the most popular sport.

by george cronin on Sep 13, 2008 9:27 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

I also think

That it was a long time before there was another championship game that good.

by NYERinSF on Sep 16, 2008 7:02 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Actually

the game was not a sellout. there were about six thousand empty seats. I do agree with you though that the game was the catalyst for the NFL’s rise to dominance in professional sports. The fact that it went to sudden death overtime really excited many fans. That and the "Violent world of Sam Huff publicity put the NFL on the map

by giant fan since 57 on Sep 13, 2008 10:00 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

I could be wrong

but wasn’t it the first nationally televised game? I always thought that was part of it too, the fact that the first ever game that so many people watched happened to also be a great game worked out perfectly for the NFL.

by cjmulrain on Sep 13, 2008 12:02 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

If I gave the impression that the greatest game ever played was a sellout it was unintentional,

but as cj points out it was the first nationally televised game and that was very important for the NFL’s sudden popularity. It wasn’t just the OT that made the game great (or unbelievably exciting) but Unitas bringing the Colts, deep in their own territory, from behind in the closing minutes and tieing it up with but seconds left to play. For me, that game is the most exciting I’ve ever witnessed save for last year’s SB, with its imposible catch by Tyree. Of course, the outcome has a lot to do with my feelings—the elation of a win contrasted by the depression of a tough, tough, tough loss. Really, until Unitas led that long drive to tie (that included three stikes to Berry) it looked like a sure win for the Giants—finally after their previous consecutive loses in title games. As I’ve said before, fate owes us for some of those losses (gale force windsfor a passing team, Tittle’s torn ligaments, etc.) including even the Colts loss (as great as Johnny U was in his career, did he ever have a better game in a crucial game?)

by george cronin on Sep 13, 2008 12:46 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

First Nationally televised NFL Championship

Believe it or not it was 1951…I googled this info..

Schilling, 2003, p. 171). The DuMont television network televised five NFL games in 1951, including the championship game between the Los Angeles Rams and the Cleveland Browns. DuMont paid $475,000 for the rights to the NFL’s annual championship games through 1955 (NFL, 1951; “Pro football and DuMont sign a $475,000 pact,” 1951). By 1953, DuMont obtained rights to broadcast a game each week (Brooks & Marsh, 1979, p. 290; Neal-Lunsford, 1992, p. 73). Both DuMont and the NFL realized the benefits of the arrangement: Nine of the twelve NFL clubs ended the 1953 and 1954 seasons in the black, thanks largely to revenue from television, while DuMont realized its largest advertising income from coverage of professional football and basketball (Heldenfels, 1994, p. 167). An internal DuMont memorandum in late 1954 notes that Nielsen ratings for professional football had risen 26% over the previous year, while ratings for NCAA football had fallen 15% from the previous year (Hubbell, 1954). At the close of the 1954 season, DuMont estimated its football coverage reached 400 million viewers (DuMont, 1955). Such success did not go unnoticed elsewhere. Archival material indicates that in early 1954, NBC was investigating the potential costs of carrying the NFL and had even met with the league’s commissioner, De Benneville “Bert” Bell, and various potential advertisers. In one memorandum written in early 1955, an NBC executive states, “I believe most strongly that NBC should carry pro-football” (Culligan, 1955, p. 1; see also Gardner, 1954; Martin, n.d.; Martin, 1955).

Despite its brief success covering professional sports, the DuMont network was “programmatically underdeveloped, poorly positioned in terms of its affiliates, and insufficiently supported by advertisers,” (MacDonald, 1994, p. 65) and folded in 1955 (Weinstein, 2004, pp. 187-189), leaving individual NFL teams to negotiate television deals with local television stations. The major teams were successful in extracting revenues from local television stations and sponsors. However, the less prominent teams residing in smaller markets failed to receive any attention from local television stations. It was under these circumstances, in late 1955, that professional football gained the attention of television executives of CBS, whose concern for attracting viewers to their television sets on Sunday afternoons ultimately helped transform football into one of the most lucrative venues for television. In broadcasting the entire 1956 National Football League season CBS shifted professional football broadcasts from a model established by Major League Baseball in which local stations carried local teams’ games to one in which networks would package, sell, and air multiple games in different regions of the country.

Interesting stuff…I lived in New Enland and watched a lot of Giants games on the CBS station in Hartford.

While preparing to watch about three NCAA games today I suddenly realized that it was not so many years ago that there were only one or two games televised each weeekend. Thank God that’s changed!

by giant fan since 57 on Sep 13, 2008 3:06 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Ah, yes, the old Dumont network, where I first saw Jackie gleson perform (on

the Cadiilac of TVs in those days—an Admiral.) Like you, I watched Giants games brodcast by Dumont as well. Unfortunately, Dumont never succeeded in establishing stations nationwide, or even in all the larger cities on the eastern seaboard. Thus cj was correct in saying that the Giants-Colts greatest game ever played was the first nationally televised NFL championship game, in fact, I believe it was the firat nationally televised NFL game, period.

by george cronin on Sep 13, 2008 7:04 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Dumont had Gleason?

Wow…I don’t remember Dumont. Did they carry The Honeymooners? I do remember though my father buying an Admiral 20" or so black and white tv in 1961 for the princely sum of $400 if I remember correctly. That was a huge amount of money then. We had to save for a long time before we got it. No Citi cards in those days.

by giant fan since 57 on Sep 13, 2008 7:41 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Jackie's first TV program was Dumont's, "Cavalcade of Stars."

Those first TVs were beyond the price range of blue collar families like mine. My brother won the Admiral in a lottery at the annual church carnival. I think TVs were the advent of globalization, with the Japanese taking over early on and driving manufacturers such as Admiral out of business. People were very skeptical of Japanese products back then. Before WWII and for at least a decade after the Japanese were notorious for producing junk, unlike Americans who were revered worldwide for making quality products.
How times have changed.

by george cronin on Sep 13, 2008 9:14 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Japanese products.

You are so right. I remember in 1964 when I saw my first Toyota. I was washing cars for a Ford Dealer when someone noticed it parked in front of the shop. We all laughed our a**es off because we knew the Japanese couldn’t even make a decent transitor radio back then.

From what I’ve read the president of Sony came to America and was so humiliated by the fact that “made in Japan” was synonomous with garbage that he went home and convinced his people to commit to quality.

by giant fan since 57 on Sep 14, 2008 6:13 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

The biggest difference maker was Dr. William Deming.

The Japanese govt brought him over in the fifties to teach TQM to its industrial execs. They followed the precpts religiously and over time Japanese products became known for their superb quality.

by george cronin on Sep 14, 2008 8:09 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Big Blue View is the best independent site on the Internet for year-round news and discussion about the New York Giants.

Community Guidelines
Start posting about the Giants »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Ivan_small
BBV Week 9 pool
Chargershorse_small
BFTB Answers Your Chargers Questions

Recent FanPosts

_1avatar_small
The Recipe
Micah_small
Things Have To Change Right?
Small
I've tried to remain optimistic
Ivan_small
BBV Week 8 prelim. results
Dbc92c5112a9b23c_small
Giants get picked as the Stone Cold Lock of the Century....of the Week
Sp_strahan_small
Bradshaw has broken bone in foot
Gwvcin_small
George Wrighster's Week 7 Review and Week 8 Preview
_1avatar_small
3 and out

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

Blogging The Boys
Pickin' & Grinnin' Week Nine
Mile High Report
Scouting Terrence Cody
Battle Red Blog
Ryan Moats Will Start Against The Colts

SPONSORS

Get Your Giants' Gear


Editor-In-Chief

Bigblueview_small Ed Valentine

Editors

Blueshirt_banter_small Jim Schmiedeberg

Authors

Tyree_believe_small cjmulrain

Moderators

Small brisulph