Matt Allen at punter, I thought he was pretty good. I agree Pettigout was more frustrating then terrible. But if your going with that standard, how is Will Allen not at DB? And how about Jonathan Carter at WR, lost to injury for the year, while standing completely still on the line of scrimmage.

My votes for coordinator, first ballot has to be John Hufnagel and Johnny Lynn. Hell will always stoke a special fire for Johnny Lynn right next to Ray.

QB: Dave Brown. More for the fact that I remember watching a game when I was a wee kid and the announcers saying “Brown and Drew Bledsoe are the 2 most promising young QB’s in the NFL” and I clung to that for 3 years, as Bledsoe became a superstar and Brown was benched for the immortal Danny Kannel.
RB: Ron Dayne
WR: Tim Carter

Norm Snead? Randy Johnson? Jerry Goldstein (sp?) As I remember, he was one of the great “practice” QBs of all time. Looked great till he got his first hit. Did Palmer ever actually play in a game?

Luke? Worst ever, no way Take any of the lines from the wilderness years. You could have replaced it with swiss cheese. If you would like, I can get the rosters. They all pretty much sucked

While many of these players never did anything after, I do remember that Maddox had at least one decent year at Pittsburgh

Running back – Bobby Duhon? Doug Kotar? Ernie Koy?

Exactly what I was hoping for. Petitgout seems to be a controversial choice, I love it.

Randy Johnson and Jerry Goldsteyn were considered, but when we held the Handley Combine out at Bayonne High School, they performed better than our nominees, only missing the targets 98 out of 100 times

Doug Kotar, I couldn’t disrepsect any Giant who left us far too soon

I thought about Ron Dixon, but two things kept him off the list:

1. If not for him, the Giants are the only team in SB history to be shut out in a Super Bowl
2. I love the “Lambuth Special” play they ran with him against the Eagles that one time, and if not for Jurevicius missing a key block at the Eagles 10 yard line, it would have worked.

I thought you would be screaming “Joe Don Looney” from the rooftops!!!!

Jerrod Bunch, Ron Dayne, Tyrone Wheatley, George Adams …

This is alot of fun

I don’t harbor any ill will towards Handley, all sins were forgiven when Plax caught that touchdown pass

I mean, look at my name, jrs1940…..a moniker I took on after the Rangers cleansed all sins in 1994. Now I wear it like a badge of honor. Same thing with Handley. After Super Bowl 42, I’m at peace with everything that happened between 1991 and 2006

Take me to the river, wash me in the water…..

should be on this list…. he’s awful, i dont care what anyone says, he misses the extra point way too often .. i hope the giants come to their senses and release the “hero” whose one job in life is to kick a ball and almost kept us out of the superbowl 3 separate times… if i was older i wouldve had a heart attack, 100%.... to all of you older guys, idk how you lived through the NFC championship. i was having heart palpitations .. RW Mcquarters and tynes almost killed me

Can’t call a guy “worst” when he kicked us into the Super Bowl. the first two kicks were just warmups, he was being dramatic

Kent Graham, one of the most mediocre starting QBs I can remember

If you looked close enough, he was starting to play well.

Could sub in Danny Kanell, though. (Shudder.)

I completely forgot we ever had Herman Moore.