Cronin's Corner: 1962 another missed opportunity
By George Cronin
[NOTE: This is the latest installment of George Cronin's look back at the Giants of yesteryear. So far, George has taken us an a history lesson from the 1930s all the way the '60s. Today, he talks about 1962.]
Giff came back in’62 and played his third position on the team, flanker, replacing Rote, who retired. The Giants won the Eastern Division again with a 12-2 record. They led the league in total offense, gaining more than 5,000 yards and scoring 35 TD passes (33 by YA.)
They met the Pack (13-0) for the NFL championship, fired up to avenge their humiliating loss in the previous year. The teams fielded 15 HOF players. Jim Taylor led the league in rushing, the only time in Jim Brown's career that he failed to gain that honor.
In 1961, despite a clear, blustery day that made passing tough, the field conditions in Lambeau were good. A snowstorm had been forecast and the field was covered hith bales of hay. The hay and snow were removed the morning of the game, and the turf was in good shape.
In ’62, an unexpected, overnight ice storm froze the Yankee Stadium field. The temperature was 13, and swirling 40 MPH winds brought the wind chill factor down to -25. Gusts blew the heavy sideline benches over. Ice formed around players’ eyelids and noses. YA talked of being snake-bitten by the weather two years in a row and of a ball frozen like a block of ice.
Green Bay players have been quoted as swearing that it was colder than the “Ice Bowl” game vs. Dallas in ’67. Hornung called it the hardest game he ever played. Lombardi as fine a football game as he'd ever seen. Blacked out in NYC, I watched this game in a crowded bar on the Jersey shore. The game plan was simple: control the clock by run, run, running Taylor, mostly on sweeps behind a wall of blockers including Hornung and the offensive line.
In the first quarter, Jerry Kramer, who earlier in the year replaced Hornung (leg injury) as placekicker, put Green Bay ahead with a field goal one, of three successes out of five attempts. He wore cleats with a kicking toe, unlike the sneaks worn by all the other players from both teams
In the second quarter, Giants FB Phil King fumbled on the Giants 28 yard line and Ray Nitschke, the Pack’s MLB recovered. On first down, Hornung hit on an option pass to the Giants 7. On the next play Taylor scored on one of the few cutbacks he made that day, which the pursuing defense overran. Later, the Giants tightened things up when CB Erich Barnes blocked a punt and one of his teammates fell on the ball for a TD. GB led at the half, 10-7.
In the second half, the Pack kept battering the Giants defense with Taylor. He needed stitches in his arm during half time, which kept opening every time he scraped them on the frozen ground during the second half. Spitting blood from a bitten tongue, Taylor heaved up from every pile up challenging the Giants to hit him harder.
By the end of the day, The Giants outgained Green Bay in yardage, 291-244, but couldn’t score again and went down to defeat 16-7, the fourth loss in a championship game in five years. Taylor carried the ball 31 times for 85 yards.
Ray Nitschke won the MVP. He played like a wild man, made tackles all over the field, deflected a pass on GB’s 10 that led to interception and recovered two fumbles. One led to a TD; the other, a FG. The Pack players awarded the team ball to Kramer for insuring the win with FGs in impossible conditions.
Allie Sherman won Coach-of-the Year honors for the second time in a row. I believe that’s the only time that has happened.
So the Giants wound up losing the championship game for the fourth time in five years. As a fan, I take the little consolation provided by the knowledge that, in the judgment of most experts, the Colts of 1958-59 (along with the Packers of 1961-62) were among the best teams to ever play in the NFL. But damn, we could have won as many as three of those games.
0 recs |
10
comments
| Add your comment
Comments
Great post George as always
But I’m curious about one thing:
How was the game blacked out in NYC? The NFL must have had some crazy TV rules in those days, and I can’t imagine watching the game in a bar at the Jersey Shore was much fun, seeing as how the “big screen” was years away from being invented, and I’m guessing bars in those days didn’t have more than oe or two TV’s
Giants fan from the womb to the tomb
by jrs1940 on
May 3, 2008 9:47 AM EDT
reply
0 recs
All home games were blacked out for quite a while after WWII
Even championship games? I guess so. Anyway, I remember seeing the game in Cape May. When I was a kid, my mother had a summer business on the shore. As I got older, I used to head that way a lot during other seasons. It wasn’t so bad watching on TV at a bar, better than listeneing on the radio.
by george cronin on
May 3, 2008 10:27 AM EDT
reply
0 recs
Wow
Could you imagine the NFL blacking out the Super Bowl in NYC?
Giants fan from the womb to the tomb
by jrs1940 on
May 3, 2008 10:39 AM EDT
reply
0 recs
Times change
Remember, pro football didn’t start to gain the poularity it has today until the Giants-Colts sudden death OT game in ‘58. The blackouts were intended to insure adequate attendance for the home teams, becuase the bulk of revenues came from ticket sales. I think that’s no longer true. Also, now TV revenues and salary caps helps keep smaller city teams competitive.
by george cronin on
May 3, 2008 11:29 AM EDT
reply
0 recs
George
I’ve seen the statistical record before, but reading your stories about those 50’s and 60’s teams really puts a human spin on what must have been a lot of heartbreaking losses year-after-year in the championship games. Makes me feel a lot less sorry for Bills fans!
It’s kinda strange that the Giants kept making the Championship Game and losing in pretty much the same time frame as the Brooklyn Dodgers kept making the World Series and losing. Ironic too that they both finally broke through only a year apart from each other, then promptly lost again! Must have been tough for people who were Dodgers AND (football) Giants fans, especially considering the Dodgers abandoned Brooklyn and promptly won 3 World Series at the same time as the Giants started their slide into the dark years.
by cjmulrain on
May 3, 2008 11:35 AM EDT
reply
0 recs
Which is worse,
four losses in a row for championship games (Including Norwood’s wide right) or one win in six games over eight years? I’ll take the latter, but I’m sure Bills fans would take the former. Anyway, I’ll talk about the Giants and Lady Luck in my next and last installment. I’d love to see our current team get to the SB five times in the next seven years (seven would be better), but..one year at a time!
by george cronin on
May 3, 2008 12:19 PM EDT
reply
0 recs
How do your remember this stuff so well?
Your memory is way better than mine. Did you cover sports as a journalist? I barely remember that game but your post did jog some of my memories. I didn’t even remember Sherman being named coach of the year twice in a row. Do you think he just benefited from the talent or was he really good? The team stunk so badly in his later coaching years. Was everyone who sang “Goodbye Allie” wrong? Did the front office fail him?
By the way I think you have enough knowledge of the old days to justify a blog devoted to it.
by giant fan since 57 on
May 4, 2008 6:16 AM EDT
reply
0 recs
Noooooooooo!
George is not allowed to go strike out on his own!!! He has to stay here. George belongs to BBV, and I am not letting him go!!!! LOL!!!
by ETVal on
May 4, 2008 9:19 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
57, never a journalist, always an avid fan.
I remember you saying a few times how bad a coach Sherman was and my replying that when he first took over he was considered a genius. I think he was a damn good offensive coach. He turned the team around by bringing in Tittle, Shofner and Joe Walton and bringing Giff back after almost two years out to play flanker. He knew what to do with those guys. He inherited the best defense in the league and screwed up royally by trrading it away. I’ve never heard a good explanation of why he did, except that he had some kind of personality flaw. They weren’t wrong to sing, “Goodby Allie.” The front office failed him in two ways: 1. By giving him a free hand; 2. By not dumping him sooner.
I have absolutely no desire to create a blog or even registering with another. I probably devote too much time to BBV as it is.
by george cronin on
May 4, 2008 10:04 AM EDT
up
reply
0 recs
Great post
and responses too. It’s a lot better trying to get a feel for those times reading something like these posts than just reading stats that just don’t connect.
We're only gonna score 17 points?
by big blue wrecking crew on
May 5, 2008 8:59 AM EDT
reply
0 recs







