Big Blue View: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: Phillies trade for OF Matt Stairs Bar-right-arrows



CRONIN'S CORNER: Giants, 1939-'49, Part I

[EDITOR'S NOTE: Throughout the off-season, George Cronin, one of our elder statesmen here at Big Blue View, will be entertaining us with stories of the Giants of yesteryear. 'Cronin's Corner' will run on Saturdays.]

From '39-'49, the Giants played for the NFL championship three times and for the Eastern Division championship twice. They lost every game. In fact, after winning the NFL championship in '38, they didn't win another until '56.

The '41 championship game, played two weeks after Pearl Harbor, drew the smallest attendance of any NFL Championship Game. The final score was Bears 14, Giants 7. I remember nothing of the game.

The country was focused on the war and the induction of millions of young men into the armed forces. My brother, who'd been married in September, '41, was drafted a few days after New Years '42. He fought in North Africa, Sicily, Italy, the Normandy landing and beyond. He was wounded a few times, for which he received purple hearts, but came home more or less in one piece.

The Giants played the Packers in the '44 NFL Championship Game and were expected to win, having already beaten them in the regular season. Playing without Bill Paschal, their leading rusher, they lost, 14-7, a bitter defeat.

I listened to the '46 championship game on the radio. It's the only championship game from the '40s that stands out in my memory. Frankie Filchock, one of my all-time favorite Giants, was the QB. He played in the NFL from '38-'46, with two years out for military service.

He was the first QB to throw a 99-yard TD (in '39, when he shared QB duties with Sammy Baugh in Washington.) He led the league in TD passes in '38 and '39 and had the best pass efficiency rating in '44.

He shares the dubious distinction with Layne, Favre and Van Brocklin (all HOFers and 100 Besters) of having thrown six picks in one game. He threw sidearm and could run with the ball.

Steve Owen needed a passer and asked Tim Mara to get Filchock. Mara traded for him and paid him huge money for those days ($35,000/year)and gave him the first multi-year contract granted to a Giants player. Injured early, Frankie had a good year running and passing and turned around a losing team, leading it to first place in the East.

He was a great QB, but played only one year with the Giants. Why then my man crush on him? Aside from the fact that he was exciting to watch, the circumstances surrounding his '46 season had an irresistible appeal to a romantic 13-year-old.

In the next installment, I'll tell you the story. There are conflicting accounts, but I'll give you the one I prefer.

0 recs | Comment 4 comments

Story-email Email | Print |

Comments

Display:

Throwing 6 picks
Is like losing 20-games in baseball....you have to be good enough that your coach won't pull you out in order to achieve the feat: Peyton Manning also threw 6 picks against the Chargers this year.

by cjmulrain on Feb 24, 2008 9:38 AM EST   0 recs

Yeah, I forgot
Anyway, Frankie's in pretty good company.  I think he did it in the game I'll be talking about in the next installment.  He played most of the game after his nose had been broken in the 1st quarter.  Thosae old bars didn't provide a lot of protection.  I remember Conerly and Unitas playing in a game in which their noses had been broken.  I'm sure there were others.

by george cronin on Feb 24, 2008 10:05 AM EST   0 recs

George
You mentioned Pearl Harbor, I seem to remember reading a story somewhere that the Giants were actually playing when Pearl Harbor was attacked, and that the game was stopped and an announcement was made for all military personnel to report for duty, are you familiar with this?

Keep up the great stories, I can't get enough of this stuff

I know the story on Filchock, look forward to your installment

Jim

by jrs1940 on Feb 24, 2008 7:46 PM EST   0 recs

Announcements for all miltary personnel to report
for duty were made all over the country.  The government's prompt call to arms reflects the consensus of historians that at the top levels of our government it was well known that the Japanese would attack once we declared an embargo.  The only controversy is whether those at the top were aware that PH would be the target.  
I know Roosevelt called Congress in session at noon to get war declared, so the timing re the Giants game (all NFL games for that matter, or any other kind of public events) is right.  It makes sense that games would have been interrupted to make the announcements.  I'm pretty sure the games were played to completion, if only because it makes sense that they would have been.  

by george cronin on Feb 24, 2008 9:13 PM EST   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

An unofficial SB Nation blog about the New York Giants

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Nfl_giants_old3_small
STRAHAN TURNS DOWN GIANTS OFFER
Stampedeblue_small
Osi Umenyiora done for the year
Neondad_small
Gridiron Hyenas?
Neondad_small
Giants Coach Extortion Bust
Strahan_small
ESPN wants to know "Who is the greatest in Giants history?"
Leesarah_small
Pennington to Dolphins
Small
Giants Giving Loyal Fans The Sack
Stephenbaker_small
Remember the Good Times with Shock
Rookieoftheyear1_small
Shockey Traded to New Orleans
Leesarah_small
Eli Manning Signed Super Bowl Program on Ebay

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Site Meter