A Thursday journey through the Giants wayback machine.....

by Jim Schmiedeberg on Oct 16, 2008 4:00 PM EDT

'Intellectual Derriere' is not only one of our new posters here at BBV but is also one of my closest friends. He was cleaning out his work e-mail, and stumbled across this exchange between he and I. We got a good laugh out of it, and hope you will, too. Remember folks, Ed has me listed down below as an "expert". Take it away Mr. Derriere (Chuck):

So I'm cleaning out old e-mail and stumble upon this gem of an e-mail chain. It started out innocent enough with the Giants signing Vonta Leach (FB - Houston) to a 2mil offer sheet. What followed was some of Jim's "Expert" opinions. I've reversed the e-mail chain for read-ability....

From: Jim [mailto:J******@******.org]
Sent: Tuesday, March 20, 2007 5:38 AM
To: Chuck
Subject: Looks like Finn is out

Bye-bye secret weapon Jim Finn

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2007/football/nfl/03/20/leach.giants.ap/index.html - (Unfortunately this link is dead now, it was a story about the Giants signing Leach to an offer sheet)

Jim
________________________________________________________
From: Chuck [mailto:c******@******.com]
Sent: Tuesday, March 20, 2007 10:04 AM
To: Jim
Subject: RE: Looks like Finn is out

Great. So a player that was cut from two teams and was only worth $850k to his previous team; the Giants give over 2 Mil a year to? Brilliant!

Chuck
_________________________________________________________
From: Jim [mailto:J******@******.org]
Sent: Tuesday, March 20, 2007 7:11 AM
To: Chuck
Subject: RE: Looks like Finn is out

Here is my thinking on this: (Pay attention here folks, here comes the "experts" opinion):

The Giants are not spending any money on players or coaches at this point because in their mind, barring a miracle, Tom Coughlin is gone at the end of the year, and they aren't going to waste time or money on players the new regime may not want. They are basically telling TC "This is it, work with what you have, we're done investing in your program."

I hope most Giants fans are smart enough to realize the Giants are giving up on this year. They locked Eli up for a few more years, in my opinion because they are dead set on getting him a coach he can prosper with for next year. I honestly think the job will be there for Charlie Weis if he wants it, and I expect ND to take a step back this year, and I think he will be ready for the change.

I can't help but think all this sitting back and doing almost nothing is part of a plan.

Jim
_________________________________________________________
From: Chuck [mailto:c******@******.com]
Sent: Tuesday, March 20, 2007 10:04 AM
To: Jim
Subject: RE: Looks like Finn is out

They have potentially spent over 2mil a year on a journeyman (at best) fullback. I would rather they did nothing. Now they have that 2mil albatross hanging around their neck for the next four years.

Hell, he could be the next Carthon. Who knows. I just can't get excited about the upcoming season.

Chuck
_________________________________________________________End of thread

Final Thought from Intellectual D:

I can't begin to express how happy I am that; A - Houston matched the offer sheet and the Giants didn't end up with VL, B - How wrong we both where about the Giants last year.

P.S. Jim, please don't post my e-mail chain after the Buffalo game where I said I would rather have Ryan Leaf than Elisha Manning at QB.

Tweet Comment 5 comments | 0 recs |

Do you like this story?

Comments

hey

I thought it was a rebuilding year after week 2

by queler on Oct 16, 2008 4:33 PM EDT reply actions

I can picture Chuck

Doing the Rodney Hampton dance… you go boy……….

"18-1, Write that Book"

by BigBl42 on Oct 16, 2008 5:04 PM EDT reply actions

That's good but...

This might be the best rambling commentary ever furnished by jrs via email…

"If they even win one game, it will be the biggest upset in sports since Douglas beat Tyson. The Giants will be so bad, they will already be losing games on the 2008 schedule before 2007 ends

Giants will be sold to Disney move to LA and become the Mighty Pirates of the Caribbean of Anaheim in Los Angeles and Hollywood, playing two home games in the LA Coliseum, two at the Rose Bowl, two at Anaheim Stadium, and 2 in Tommorowland at DisneyLand. They will go 0-16 every year for the next 10 years, finally forcing them to fire 70 year old head coach Tom Coughlin and rehire Jim Fassel, saying "Coughlin was just too strict, what this team needs is a players coach!"

The expansion NY Giants will return in 2008, back out of their deal with the Jets for a new stadium, and build their own new stadium across the street. Then the Giants will buy all the land from the state, and tell the Jets to go to hell"

In his defense, I did bait him. I know, I know…that doesn’t seem possible.

by Intellectual Derriere on Oct 16, 2008 8:45 PM EDT reply actions